Rap Lyrics Now Admissible as Court Evidence: A Dangerous Precedent (Guest Column)

  • 📰 Variety
  • ⏱ Reading Time:
  • 43 sec. here
  • 2 min. at publisher
  • 📊 Quality Score:
  • News: 21%
  • Publisher: 63%

United States Headlines News

United States Latest News,United States Headlines

'Great music is more often than not rooted in storytelling, and by imposing criminal consequences for a story told through an artistic medium, the court here threatens to stifle creativity and limit the scope of artistic expression,' writes dinalapolt.

, The State of Maryland’s highest court ruled that rap lyrics may be admitted in court as evidence of a defendant’s guilt. This blatantly racist decision is a travesty that sets a dangerous precedent.

Maryland’s highest court took the case on appeal and affirmed Montague’s conviction, finding that the danger of unfair prejudice posed by the admission of the lyrics does not substantially outweigh the lyrics’ probative value. In making this determination, the Court wildly understates the unfair prejudice posed by the use of this type of evidence.

Ignorant of this perspective, the Court’s opinion hastily draws conclusions from Montague’s lyrics, making up connections between the lyrics and the crime that are simply not there. The Court uses this poorly substantiated analysis toward its finding that the lyrics had an “unmistakable factual connection” to the crime. It attempts to put all rap lyrics into the categories of historical fact and fiction, failing to understand that hip-hop, like most art, is more complex than that.

 

Thank you for your comment. Your comment will be published after being reviewed.
Please try again later.

dinalapolt Well this is..stupid.

dinalapolt Maybe don't confess to crime in song, if you consider rap 'song'...which it isn't.

dinalapolt Only rap?

dinalapolt People trying to pretend that they understand something that they know absolutely nothing about.

dinalapolt Shame is the one thing that racists, and racist institutions, never feel.

dinalapolt This needs to go to the US Supreme Court.

dinalapolt Only in America. Smmfh. I call BS. The court is dead wrong for this! Meanwhile, white supremacists get TF away with bloody murder AND sedition!

dinalapolt yeah i sell dope down on Pratt St. everyday, Got me an illegal gun that I bought under the freeway. barsprisonbars

dinalapolt Dang that new Fortnite music pack hitting

dinalapolt if this is the case, they better keep the same energy to those bands that be self snitching too

Slippery slope, talking in general about drunk driving is different than straight up admitting to murder that you are on trial for lol

This violates the 1st Amendment

dinalapolt

dinalapolt Please listen to NPR ‘s Louder Than a Riot, which is about this very issue.

dinalapolt Wow

dinalapolt I don't like this at all, you can rap about taking your competitors down and then get arrested if anything bad happens to them! There will have to be air tight evidence before they use this! I say I could kill my husband, it doesn't mean I'm going to, he just annoyed me!

dinalapolt trash

dinalapolt This has been going on for almost 20 years in Louisiana.

dinalapolt ACLU help!!

dinalapolt You just don't come up with incriminating lyrics. That will settle it.

dinalapolt This is unacceptable

AdrienneLaw dinalapolt the 'news' isnt even expected to be facts, but... there is no fixing a country that doesnt even want better

dinalapolt Hmm.. take them seriously, but not literally. Where have we heard this before? The left fed the beast, now they’re shocked it plans to devour them. Tough.

dinalapolt Lol. Everything is racist.

We have summarized this news so that you can read it quickly. If you are interested in the news, you can read the full text here. Read more:

 /  🏆 108. in US

United States Latest News, United States Headlines

Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.

Vanessa Bryant hits out at famous rapper over insensitive lyrics about late husband Kobe BryantVanessa Bryant hits out at rapper Meek Mills over insensitive Kobe Bryant lyrics
Source: hellomag - 🏆 24. / 68 Read more »

Selena Gomez and Rauw Alejandro's 'Baila Conmigo' Lyrics Capture the Thrill of New LoveSelena Gomez unveiled her second Spanish single at midnight, 'Baila Conmigo' with Rauw Alejandro, giving a more flirtatious and playful track to complement her first release. Here, the lyrics and their English translation. bekindalways_lo BAILA CONMIGOO 🔥💃 SelenaSourceFR BUY and Stream Baila Conmigo
Source: ELLE Magazine (US) - 🏆 472. / 51 Read more »

It’s Been 10 Years Since Adele Released “21” — Do You Still Remember The Album's Lyrics?That's right, we've officially been scream-singing along to 'Rolling in the Deep' for TEN YEARS!
Source: BuzzFeed - 🏆 730. / 51 Read more »

YouTube declines to ban video with anti-Asian lyrics amid staff outcryYouTube is declining to ban a video by hip-hop artist YG containing anti-Asian lyrics, despite a drive among staffers to have the song removed from the platform. But youtube will ban shoenice for drinking liquor. What a bunch of clowns Oh god. theyre complicit in so much violence
Source: NBCNews - 🏆 10. / 86 Read more »

Selena Gomez's 'De Una Vez' Lyrics Capture the Beauty of Overcoming Heartbreak'This is the beginning of something I’ve wanted to explore for so long,' Gomez tweeted of her first Spanish single.
Source: ELLE Magazine (US) - 🏆 472. / 51 Read more »