With the future of our democracy at stake, it's time for Congress to leave timidity at the chamber doors and compel Trump's team to testify about Jan. 6, Glenn Kirschner writes.
Congress has the power to force an appearance from Trump's inner circle.
By, MSNBC Opinion ColumnistThe House select committee investigating the Jan. 6 attack on the U.S. Capitol has issued subpoenas seekingtestimony and documents from four Trump administration officials: former presidential adviser Steve Bannon, former chief of staff Mark Meadows, former deputy chief of staff Dan Scavino and former Pentagon official Kash Patel.
During Donald Trump’s time as president, congressional subpoenas seemed to have been viewed by executive branch officials as something akin to party invitations.The committee sent all four men letters making clear each has information “relevant to understanding important activities that led to and informed the events at the Capitol on January 6, 2021, and relevant to former President Trump’s activities and communications in the period leading up to and on January 6.” These subpoenas likely will set off a chain of events that will say much about the pace and direction of the committee’s investigation but also about the future health of our democracy.
During Donald Trump’s time as president, congressional subpoenas seemed to have been viewed by executive branch officials as something akin to party invitations that could be accepted or rejected with little or no consequence. When subpoena recipients weren’t ignoring lawfully issued congressional subpoenas entirely, they were challenging the subpoenas in court, making baseless claims of nonexistent privileges and immunities and weaponizing the delay built into the court system in an attempt to run out the clock. Former White House counsel Don McGahn battled a congressional subpoena in court for more than two years and ultimately won the war of attrition. headtopics.com
With this new round of congressional subpoenas, we will now see if Congress and the courts have learned anything from that time or if they will again let witnesses ignore their subpoenas or exploit court delays in an effort to run out the clock.Here are some of the issues that will arise as a result of these four subpoenas.
Some of the individuals may assert a claim of executive privilege in an attempt to defeat the subpoena. Indeed, Trump has already threatened to invoke executive privilege to block the select committee’s subpoenas. Unfortunately for Trump, Biden, not any former president,
makes the ultimate decisionsregarding executive privilege questions.Second, executive privilege does not apply to anyone who was a private citizen at the time he or she was speaking with the president. Bannon was a private citizen on and around Jan. 6, a second reason an executive privilege claim to block his testimony will fail.
Third, although it has not been directly tested in the courts, there is a strong argument that if the evidence or testimony sought by a congressional subpoena contains evidence of crime (such as plotting and executing an attempted overthrow of our democracy), then the crime-fraud exception trumps any privilege asserted to try to keep the evidence under wraps. headtopics.com
Sept. 24, 202107:32If witnesses refuse to honor the subpoenas, will Congress use all the tools at its disposal to aggressively enforce compliance? There are three ways Congress can enforce its subpoenas: through civil enforcement, criminal contempt and through its power of inherent contempt.
Civil enforcement involves Congress going to court to begin the long, inefficient process of litigating the enforceability of subpoenas. This approach failed spectacularly when Congress used it in an attempt to force McGahn to testify about what Volume II of the Mueller report called Trump’s possible obstruction of justice. McGahn weaponized long court delays, successfully ran out the clock and was never compelled to testify.
The criminal contempt approach relies on the assistance of the Department of Justice to pursue a criminal contempt case in court to force compliance with congressional subpoenas. This was not a viable option when Trump was president and William Barr was attorney general because Barr was far more interested in protecting Trump than assisting Congress in securing testimony that might have incriminated Trump. In a Biden administration with Attorney General Merrick Garland in charge, criminal contempt is back in play as an enforcement option.
With Attorney General Merrick Garland in charge, criminal contempt is back in play as an enforcement option.The Supreme Court emphasized the importance and value of Congress’ contempt power in 1821 when it ruled that Congress’ power to “hold someone in contempt is essential to ensure that Congress is not exposed to every indignity that rudeness, caprice or even conspiracy may make against it.” In the 1920s, Congress arrested and confined Mally Daugherty when he ignored a subpoena in connection with the Teapot Dome scandal, and the next decade it used its inherent contempt power to arrest William MacCracken, an aviation industry lawyer involved in the divvying up of airmail contracts by the U.S. Post Office. The Supreme Court reaffirmed then that Congress was within its power to compel MacCracken’s testimony and arrest him for defiance. headtopics.com
Congress’ refusal to deploy its inherent power of contempt during the Trump years left our republic weak and susceptible to attack from within. With the future of our democracy at stake, it is time for Congress to leave timidity at the chamber doors and compel witnesses to testify about their knowledge of the incidents leading up to and culminating in the Jan 6. attack on the U.S. Capitol.Read more: MSNBC »
Auston Matthews is the NHL's must-see superstar
The Maple Leafs center is far from a traditional NHL superstar -- but he might be exactly the kind of star it needs.
At the same time, our nation needs to be prepared to hear and accept the ugly truth that is soon to be told. What would happen to the average guy who ignored a subpoena? Everyone should have the exact same consequences. No exceptions!!! If you plead the 5th … then all charges aren’t disputed and trial moves forward
This story has lost all credibility. The US Capital was breached. Officers pushed forward and struck people with their shields after the US Capital was already breached. Why is it we have not heard any testimony on who and how the US Capital was breached?
Opinion | Proof that team Trump knew it was lying all along.steve_vladeck: Fmr. President Trump’s Jan. 6 logic was embarrassingly thin, according to these memos. steve_vladeck He needs to be held accountable. steve_vladeck President Biden Will Not Assert Executive Privilege on Matters Pertaining to January 6th | Floodgates Will Now Open | Get Up-to-Speed NoOneUnscripted steve_vladeck horrible
Biden will allow Jan. 6 investigators access to Trump records, White House saysNEW: President Biden will not shield fmr. President Trump's records from the congressional committee investigating the Jan. 6 riot at the U.S. Capitol by invoking executive privilege, White House Press Secretary Jen Psaki says. Good. Why would Biden? Trump tried to overturn Biden's election and take over America he needs to be held accountable!
Judge orders Trump Org. to address subpoenas by New York attorney general for company recordsA New York judge has ordered the Trump Organization to submit a report next week to the New York Attorney General in an effort to resolve a long-running dispute over subpoenas for records, according to an unsealed order. To all those Bitcoiner’s working from home Bitcoin trading options Here's a little tip: Get a trusted Bitcoin expert and stick with her lisamiaBTC Invest and play at similar times each day. Because : In times of chaos, your investment is your anchor to success There will be massive amounts of popcorn consumed. 🍿🍿🍿 Can you run the story on Hunter Biden's laptop now that it has been verified?
Trump Organization Must Comply With New York State Subpoenas, Judge RulesA New York state judge ordered the Trump Organization to turn over documents subpoenaed by the state attorney general’s office, indicating that a 2½-year civil-fraud investigation into the former president’s business affairs is still active Lock him up. Meaning He’s Guilty , eh? To all those Bitcoiner’s working from home Bitcoin trading options Here's a little tip: Get a trusted Bitcoin expert and stick with her lisamiaBTC Invest and play at similar times each day. Because : In times of chaos, your investment is your anchor to success
Trump supporter who took House Speaker Nancy Pelosi's beer at Capitol riot pleads guiltyDuring the U.S. Capitol riot Jan. 6, Trump supporter Andrew Craig Ericson plopped his feet up on a table inside House Speaker Nancy Pelosi's conference room and posed for a photo. JeffreyMeursing morgfair Why are these pleas so lenient? I just don’t understand. Guilty, and should be in prison for a very long time.
Analysis: The Quad summit is a rare mark of continuity between Trump and Biden'Overall, the meeting is a sign that four key democracies in the Asia-Pacific region are feeling pressure to respond to China's power. And the alliance architecture in the region is evolving as a result,' write StCollinson and husca | Analysis StCollinson husca ethiopia Why UNESCO silent? The Church of Lalibela and various monuments are surrounded by the terrorist TLLF. World heritage must be protected under international law Why is the world silent? Why not oppose this terrorist group?