Opinion | South Korea Wants to Declare Peace—Without Peace

Seoul’s government wants Biden to sign onto empty words that won’t deter Pyongyang’s aggression.

North Korea, South Korea

11/30/2021 9:15:00 AM

From WSJopinion: Empty words won’t move the peninsula any closer to peace, writes Nicholas Eberstadt. An end-of-war declaration would help the Kim Jong Un regime get back on its feet and back to its familiar menacing playbook.

Seoul ’s government wants Biden to sign onto empty words that won’t deter Pyongyang’s aggression.

Nicholas EberstadtNov. 28, 2021 3:27 pm ETNorth Korean leader Kim Jong Un prepares to shake hands with South Korean President Moon Jae-in in Panmunjom on the Korean border, April 27, 2018.Photo:/Associated PressSouth Korea’s “Sunshiners” in President Moon Jae-in’s administration have nothing to show for years of solicitousness to

Kim Jong Un, and Mr. Moon’s presidency is nearing its end. So they are doubling down, trying to stage a unilateral “end of war“ declaration—a bit of diplomatic theater asserting the Korean War is formally over, no matter that the North says. The goal is to rope the U.S. in.

Press reports from Seoul suggest the Biden team has been going along with this charade. Washington has said little publicly about the initiative, but Sunshiners in the South, who have been pressing it on Mr. Biden since his inauguration, claim a joint U.S.-South Korea end-of-war declaration is in its “final stages.” headtopics.com

PG&E's criminal probation to end amid ongoing safety worries

Let’s hope the reports are wrong. Pantomime statecraft and make-believe breakthroughs can’t enhance Korean security—though they could very well make the peninsula a more dangerous place.In Sunshine (or “engagement”) doctrine—a theory of international relations—the signing of “peace declarations” has been a fixation for decades. For true believers, these declarations are talismanic: Somehow they will end peninsular hostilities. Believers never lose faith when the magic fails to work.

In 2007, in an earlier era of Blue House Sunshine, President Roh Moo Hyun and Kim Jong Il signed a joint statement in Pyongyang resolving, among other things, to “put an end to military hostilities, mitigate tensions and guarantee peace on the Korean Peninsula.”

North-South peace didn’t materialize. Instead, the Kim regime went on to sink a South Korean military vessel, shell civilians on a South Korean island near the Northern Limit Line, set off five atomic devices, and launch vast numbers of short- and long-range offensive missiles.

'A No-Brainer': Lawmakers Urge Pelosi to Hold Vote on Stock Trading Ban

Nowadays, Kim Jong Un won’t talk to Mr. Moon about a peace declaration—or anything else. (Pyongyang’s propaganda chief, Kim’s sister Kim Yo Jong, dismisses Mr. Moon as a “parrot raised in America.”) So Mr. Moon has pivoted and is now pressuring the U.S. to provide him with a joint declaration instead. headtopics.com

A bilateral “declaration” would serve obvious purposes for Mr. Moon and his party, whose nominee for the March presidential election is running far behind his conservative opponent in the polls. But a pretend celebration of the end of the Korean War will do no favors for the U.S.-South Korea alliance. Demonstrating a lack of seriousness about genuine security threats is almost certain to have serious real-world consequences.

With an end-of-war declaration by Seoul and Washington—the world’s only two countries committed by treaty to defend against North Korean aggression—denuclearization of the North would become effectively an abandoned global objective. How do you mobilize the international community to press North Korea on its nukes when you are throwing an end-of-war party for yourself?

US Puts Troops on Standby as War Tensions Over Ukraine Mount

By signaling that things aren’t as bad as we thought with the North, the declaration also stands to set back the international North Korea human-rights movement. And no matter how much the alliance tries to spin the declaration, Pyongyang can bank on an international law-enforcement break: for cybercrime, terror-network commerce and other illicit financial operations.

Empty words won’t move the peninsula any closer to peace because the threat of war in Korea today is set by the North, as it always has been. Pyongyang is still committed to wiping South Korea off the map. That is what its nuclear arsenal, missile program and million-man army are all about. headtopics.com

Kim Jong Un won’t be appeased by an “end of war” declaration from reviled U.S. “imperialists” and their South Korean “puppets.” He would regard such a gesture as a sign of weakness—a concession inviting still more demands. While deeming Mr. Moon’s end-of-war declaration “an admirable idea,” Kim Yo Jong, his sister, insisted that dialogue with the South would require an end to “hostile policies”—that is, an end to the U.S.-South Korea alliance, closing of U.S. bases in the South, and lifting of economic sanctions against North Korean proliferation.

As soon as that document is signed, the U.N. Command—the multilateral defense structure that still includes other international forces in Korean peacekeeping—would be doomed to vanish, as the North has long wished. The U.S.-South Korean alliance would come under greater scrutiny in America. After all, isn’t the Korean conflict the original “endless war”?

China and Russia would be emboldened, too. They would take the declaration as an invitation to violate the United Nations Security Council’s North Korea sanctions at will and to lobby for lifting those sanctions.One immediate loser will be America’s key Asian ally. Such virtue-signaling in the Korean Peninsula would leave Japan more exposed and less secure. Throughout the postwar era, the U.S. has been one of Tokyo’s only reliable friends. Japanese leaders would start to question American credibility and act accordingly. Other allies would do the same.

At the moment North Korea seems all but incapacitated, overwhelmed by its Covid-19 emergency and the ensuing economic crisis that Pyongyang’s own mismanagement exacerbated. An end-of-war declaration would help the Kim regime get back on its feet and back to its familiar menacing playbook.

Mr. Eberstadt holds the Henry Wendt Chair in Political Economy at the American Enterprise Institute.Journal Editorial Report: The week's best and worst from Kim Strassel, Mary O'Grady, Allysia Finley and Dan Henninger. Images: AP/Getty Images Composite: Mark Kelly

Copyright ©2021 Dow Jones & Company, Inc. All Rights Reserved. 87990cbe856818d5eddac44c7b1cdeb8Appeared in the November 29, 2021, print edition.

Read more: The Wall Street Journal »

Jim Chanos says the notion that the Fed will always bail out the stock market is dangerous

Short-seller Jim Chanos said the belief that the Federal Reserve will always rescue the stock market from steep losses is reckless. Read more >>

61 Passengers On 2 Flights From South Africa To Netherlands Tested Positive For COVID-19Officials later confirmed that 13 had the omicron variant. How do you get that many in just two flights? Does nobody in South Africa wear masks or get vaccinated? WHO warns : ' PILE UP the populations in URBAN AREAS to support land & rental SPECULATION-MASS Trade & Tourism-INTENSIVE agriculture...it's CRIMINAL Let's CHANGETerritory & Town REPLANNING-direct & economic DEMOCRACY-tax EVASION-social ECOLOGY-education-sanitary PREVENTION ' Who were all vaccinated. Crazy.

Widow of South Korea's last dictator issues apology over brutal ruleThe widow of South Korea ’s last military dictator issues a brief apology over the “pains and scars” caused by her husband Chun Doo-hwan's brutal rule as people pay their final respects to him.

Omicron Variant Isn’t Deadly, South African Medical Chair ClaimsA South African doctor said Sunday that symptoms of the Omicron variant apppear to be mild and can be treated at home. Dr. Angelique Coetzee, a private practitioner and chair of the South African M… Profoundly irresponsible reporting based on anecdotal evidence

Widow of South Korea's last dictator issues apology over brutal ruleThe widow of South Korea ’s last military dictator issues a brief apology over the “pains and scars” caused by her husband Chun Doo-hwan's brutal rule as people pay their final respects to him.

The 10 Best Ellipticals To Max Out Your Home WorkoutsThe best ellipticals give you a full-body workout without putting too much pressure your joints. Octane?

Chrishell Just Shaded Justin For Marrying Someone She Once Knew ‘Well’ Before Their DivorceShe doesn't care if he 'wants to have 50 wives.'