Criminals have been stealing unemployment payments directly from recipients' accounts during the pandemic. Our investigation found that a cost-saving, but out-dated technology fueled the theft. LesliePicker reports.
Thousands of people who’ve received unemployment have complained that their benefits were stolen from their accounts, according to an analysis by CNBC.
The suit Moon joined alleges that the firm "failed to take reasonable steps to protect plaintiffs' and class members' benefits from fraud." Filed initially in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California, the complaint said that Bank of America failed to implement "fraud preventing" chip technology in the plaintiffs' cards, making them "readily susceptible to cloning."
Brian Danitz, partner at Cotchett, Pitre & McCarthy and lead plaintiffs' attorney for the class-action suit, said that after he filed the case, he received more than 800 calls "from people who wanted to join."In that case, a San Francisco judge issued a preliminary injunction last month that prevents Bank of America from denying fraud claims and freezing accounts based on its automated filter.
In response to the injunctive relief, Bank of America said it goes "well beyond what is required by law." The firm said in court documents that from October 2020 through March 2021, about 255,000 fraud claims were filed, of which the firm approved repayments to about half. headtopics.com
The bank said that part of the risk is that criminals will falsely claim fraud and then obtain provisional credits, something that has cost the firm $200 million in 2020 in California alone, according to court documents. A provisional credit is one that is temporarily added to an account as a fraud claim is evaluated. Based on the outcome of a review, it can be made permanent or removed.
"No more food in the house"Vanessa Rivera and her son.Source: Vanessa RiveraLegitimate recipients say they've been caught in the crosshairs. Single moms Candace Koole, 29, and Vanessa Rivera, 30, said they had a similar experience to Moon's. Koole, a doula, and Rivera, a lien negotiator, said they became unemployed last spring and were granted California benefits.
Koole discovered her funds were missing when she was trying to buy food at the grocery. She said she was unable to quickly recoup the $9,000 that had been stolen."I never knew if I was gonna be homeless. I never knew if...you know, if I was going to be able to get birthday presents for my kid," Koole said in an interview with CNBC. "I never knew what was going on. It was around Christmastime, that was also really hard."
When Rivera noticed $800 of benefits were stolen, she said she had to drain her family's savings."At one point, I had to actually break my son's piggy bank 'cause I didn't have gas and he didn't have — we didn't have — like, no more food in the house," Rivera told CNBC. The two are also plaintiffs in the same class-action lawsuit as Moon. headtopics.com
Bank of America did not comment on Moon, Koole and Rivera's situations. The bank said in a statement to CNBC that its "No. 1 goal always has been to ensure legitimate recipients could access their benefits."Bill Halldin, a spokesman for the firm, said that last year it increased its team serving these programs "from several hundred to more than 6,000 people, dramatically reducing wait times as we answered calls and reviewed claims." Halldin said the bank committed to "additional measures to help unemployment recipients who have been victimized by fraud receive their benefits as quickly as possible."
The higher cost of chipsCandace Koole and her son.Source: Candace KooleMoon, Koole and Rivera said that their debit cards did not include chips.Card experts told CNBC that prepaid government cards typically lack chips because they can be about 50% more expensive to produce. Additionally, unlike typical debit and credit cards for bank customers, these benefits cards are temporary — lasting just several months, until the recipient finds full time employment.
CNBC obtained an agreement between Bank of America and California to distribute government benefits from 2016. In it, the state only requested a magnetic stripe, never a chip, therefore, the bank did not need to include chips in the cards it issued for Californians.
California recently extended its contract with Bank of America, although the bank told CNBC that it "would like to exit this business as soon as possible."Bank of America recently ceased this type of work in Iowa, Kansas, Maryland and Nevada. headtopics.com
U.S. Bank, Comerica and KeyBank are the other three largest distributors of unemployment benefits. U.S. Bank and Comerica did not respond to CNBC's requests for comment. KeyBank declined to provide any further commentary on fraud incidents due to ongoing investigations.
In the meantime, California and other states are looking to ameliorate the onslaught of transaction fraud that proliferated in their systems during the pandemic."I have to imagine that if there was anti-fraud chip technology in these cards, there'd be an awful lot less fraud," said assembly member David Chiu, a Democrat, who is spearheading reform to California's Employment Development Department, which manages the benefits on behalf of the state.
Unemployment cards from California do not contain security chips.Source: CNBCAs part of a package of bills, California lawmakers are looking to allow unemployment-insurance recipients to bypass cards altogether to deposit funds directly into their regular bank accounts.
California's Employment Development Department, as well as Bank of America, told CNBC that they're in the process of transitioning to cards with chips in them to improve security for recipients.Maryland recently transitioned away from debit cards to direct deposits or paper checks for unemployment insurance. Nevada is the only other state that doesn't allow for direct deposit, but recently switched vendors with new cards that include chips, the state told CNBC.
Other states, like Oklahoma, are using technological solutions for their recent fraud problems. IDEMIA provides identity verification solutions for 34 state agencies, using facial recognition and biometric identification technology.Oklahoma's Employment Security Commission is one of those agencies, having implemented the security solution in December 2020. Shelley Zumwalt, executive director of the commission, said the state was able to prevent about 40% of fraud within the first 30 days of implementing the IDEMIA solution.
"While we had a global health pandemic, we had a national pandemic in terms of identity fraud and theft," said Matt Thompson, senior vice president of civil identity for North America at IDEMIA.For those who say their benefits were already stolen, the main way to replenish those funds is through the banks that oversee the accounts and debit cards.
Ultimately, Moon, Koole and Rivera were given a credit from Bank of America for their missing funds. But they say that their lives had already been upended."This is people's lives that you're messing with," Rivera said. "I feel very, like, punched in the gut."Read more: CNBC »
Boris Johnson: World leader's struggle with umbrella draws laughter - CNN Video
CNN's John Berman pokes fun at British Prime Minister Boris Johnson after the world leader engaged in an epic struggle with an umbrella.
LesliePicker I say end the incentive LesliePicker That's why you need to take what CEOs say with a gram of salt when they talk about their cost efficient process LesliePicker Criminals “helping solve the labor shortage.”
Child tax credit payments started hitting bank accounts today. Here's what you need to know.Most qualifying families will automatically receive the expanded payments, but those who don't have to file taxes or haven't done so will need to update their information with the IRS. Thank you JoeBiden SpeakerPelosi and SenSchumer
What you need to know about the expanded child tax creditIf you have kids, you might see up to $300 in your bank account for each child, the first of many payments this year courtesy of the expanded federal child tax credit. Here's what you need to know: Someone is posting on Facebook that people should turn this down as it requires repayment What is the truth?
Big Brother Blowout: Twitter Cracks Up at Evicted Houseguest's Excuse, Are Loving New HOHAfter a wild first week in the house, swimsuit designer Alyssa found herself facing off against account exec Travis -- who went home first, and who rose to power next? (via toofab) TooFab WHAT TO WATCH THIS WEEKEND?... 👇 FACE LIFT NO SURGERY! Catch my Talcum Powder Face Lift Hack LINKED BELOW 👇 PLEASE SUBSCRIBE TO MY CHANNEL AND TURN ON POST NOTIFICATIONS, THANK YOU. makeup beauty YouTuber YouTube friday weekendvibes TooFab Man i cant believe how many people go nuts for this show lol. I guess people really love the drama shows. :)
The 8 Funniest Accounts on TikTokIf you need a moment to look down at your phone and laugh, here are the 8 funniest TikToks to follow now:
NPR Cookie Consent and Choicesgood luck Here’s what you need to know. The more we print dollars, the worse it will get for average Americans. The same people who pretend that they care about you and your family are handing billions to the 1% as we speak. We are approaching the point of no return for the middle class…
California Legislature Approves First-Ever State Guaranteed Income Program, Report SaysCalifornia lawmakers have unanimously approved the creation of what is set to become the first state-funded guaranteed income plan in the U.S.