The details of the harassment campaign waged by former members of eBay's private security team against a suburban couple who published a niche e-commerce newsletter have shown the stunning lengths some companies will go to hit back at their critics
Six former employees were recently named in federal charges that were an indication of the lengths some companies will go to hit back at detractors.
Credit...John G Mabanglo/EPA, via ShutterstockByNicole PerlrothJune 27, 2020Last summer, members of eBay’s private security team sent live roaches and a bloody pig mask to the home of a suburban Boston couple who published a niche e-commerce newsletter.
The harassment campaign, which also included physical surveillance, sending pornographic videos to the couple’s neighbors, posting ads inviting sexual partners to the couple’s home and an attempt to attach a tracking device to their car, was detailed earlier this month in a federal indictment against six former eBay employees.
The lurid,51-page indictment, describing how the employees of a multibillion-dollar company were loosed in what authorities described as an unhinged and illegal effort to intimidate critics, drew national attention to the stunning lengths some tech companies will go when responding to their critics.
Silicon Valley companies have stacked what they often call their “trust and safety” teams with former police officers and national intelligence analysts. More often than not, their work is well within the law: protecting executives and intellectual property, fending off blackmail attempts and spotting theft. They conduct background checks on companies that could be acquisition targets and they ensure employees aren’t doing anything illegal.
But the industry’s intense focus on reputation can lead their security units astray. Those perils were laid bare when federal authorities revealed the charges against the eBay employees.“Most companies, especially established high-tech companies, have units within them that do this kind of work, respond in as close to real time as they can to online criticism of the company, to take steps to protect the brand,” Andrew Lelling, U.S. attorney for the District of Massachusetts, said. But, he added, “I can tell you that at least internally, we have never seen a company that did something like this before.”
Prosecutors charged the six eBay employees with conspiracy to commit cyberstalking and witness tampering, but noted that eBay’s campaign against the husband-and-wife publishing duo was ordered up by senior executives.“I want her DONE,” Steven Wymer, eBay’s former communications chief, told James Baugh, the company’s former senior director of safety and security. “She is a biased troll who needs to get BURNED DOWN.”
In case there was any confusion, Mr. Wymer added, “I want to see ashes.”ImageSteven Wymer, eBay’s former communications chief.Credit...Mike Coppola/Getty ImagesContacted this past week, Mr. Wymer, who was not one of the employees charged in the indictment, said, “I would never condone or participate in any such activity.” He added that he was constrained in what he could say beyond that. EBay said in a statement that “neither the company nor any current eBay employee was indicted.”
Private security teams have long been part of corporate America, among them insurers’ fraud investigators and the “seed police,” as farmers call investigators for the agricultural giant Monsanto who secretly videotape farmers, infiltrate community meetings and recruit informants in their hunt for patent infringement.
These private detective teams, which typically operate under fraud divisions, are projected to grow into a $23.3 billion global industry this year from a $17.3 billion industry in 2018, accordingto Grand View Research.Few industries have embraced the notion of private security as much as tech. One Silicon Valley investigator, who spoke on the condition of anonymity because of nondisclosure agreements, said a start-up executive had paid his firm $50,000 over one weekend to root out employees he believed were plotting his ouster. (They were.) The total tab for the work was as much as half a million dollars.
ImageA placard displaying photographs of some of the evidence in the eBay case: a bloody-pig mask and a book, “Surviving Loss of a Spouse.”Credit...Cj Gunther/EPA, via ShutterstockBut as with the eBay team, these private security groups are sometimes accused of crossing legal lines.
In 2006, for example, investigators hired by Hewlett-Packard were caught rifflingthrough reporters’ trash cansand phone records. About a year ago, Tesla made headlines for its aggressive efforts to root out and punish an employee, Martin Tripp, who had tipped reporters off to waste at the carmaker’s Nevada factory.
According to police reports and whistle-blower complaints filed by two Tesla security operators with the Securities and Exchange Commission, Tesla was accused of hacking into Mr. Tripp’s phone, having him followed by private investigators and passing along an
anonymous, false tip to the local authoritiesthat Mr. Tripp planned to shoot up Tesla’s factory.“Tesla’s investigators were tailing him, showing up at weird places, and completely spooked him,” Robert Mitchell, Mr. Tripp’s lawyer, said in an interview. Mr. Tripp has since moved to Hungary out of fears for his family’s safety.
Tesla did not respond to requests for comment, but the company has sued Mr. Tripp for $167 million for what it has said was data theft. Mr. Tripp has filed a countersuit for defamation and unspecified damages. Both suits are ongoing.When working for tech companies, private investigators have advantages over traditional law enforcement: They have access to more data, deal with far less red tape, and they have the ability to quickly cross jurisdictions and borders.
ImageJustin Zeefe, the president of Nisos, a security firm in Virginia that has worked for tech companies on a wide range of cases.Credit...Emma Howells for The New York TimesJustin Zeefe, a former intelligence officer who is now the president of Nisos, a security firm in Virginia, said his company has worked for tech companies on a wide range of cases. On one occasion, they learned that a company’s overseas suppliers had ties to foreign intelligence agencies.
Another client asked his firm to determine whether an acquisition target had been infiltrated by foreign hackers. Yet another hired Nisos to determine the source of multiple cyberattacks. It turned out to be the work of a competitor that had intercepted the company’s Wi-Fi from an apartment rented across the street.
Joe Sullivan, the chief information security officer at the internet company Cloudflare, still remembers the frantic call he received from a colleague while working as a security executive at Facebook several years ago.She had met a man on Match.com who claimed to work in construction in San Jose, Calif., and he had convinced her to send him a topless photo. He was threatening to email the photo to the entire company if she did not pay him $10,000.
With her permission, Mr. Sullivan’s team took over her account and redirected her extortionist to a payment scheme that they knew would reveal his identity. They determined he was a former Google intern living in Nigeria.Mr. Sullivan’s team hired Nigerian contractors to confront him. He confessed and surrendered access to his computer and online accounts, which showed he was extorting female executives across Silicon Valley. Investigators were able to destroy the nude photos and warned his victims not to pay.
It could have taken years, Mr. Sullivan said, for law enforcement to identify the extortionist and even longer for Nigerian authorities to do something about it.Mr. Sullivan learned that lesson as a security executive at eBay in 2006.Romanian fraudsters were running rampant on eBay
, and Romanian authorities refused to address the problem. It was only after Mr. Sullivan’s team shut off eBay access to all of Romania — with a message blaming eBay’s shuttering on Romanian law enforcement’s refusal to pursue online criminals — that Romanian police took action.
But Mr. Sullivan’s experience shows how easily tech’s aggressive security tactics can run into trouble. In 2016, two hackers approached Uber with security flaws that allowed them to obtain login credentials for more than 57 million riders and drivers, and the pair demanded a $100,000 payout in return.
Mr. Sullivan, who had recently joined Uber from Facebook, ran the same playbook he used in the Nigerian extortion case, pushing the hackers into a payment scheme to deduce their identities. Uber’s security team eventually confronted the men at their homes with nondisclosure agreements and asked them to destroy the data.Read more: The New York Times »
Well, that was the final nail in the coffin eBay And how does the Tymes hit back at critics? Soooo many crazy people like Steven Wymer out there! 🤢 I wonder how this fits into the times's Democratic narrative since almost everything else it publishes appears to be written for it by a democratic Think Tank
Mmmm hmmmm... High Pitched Greeney´s ggreenwald benefactor Revenge of the Nerds... Kind of like how cnn and CillizzaCNN blackmailed a meme-making teenager to never commit wrongthink again. power and use it to sleepy the terrorist regimes in Iran Qatar and Turkey Qaraj as they deceived him and his president Abumama They also deceived him and his president, Aboma, before he fell asleep. They managed to spread their terrorism in the region, and the world is American.
Huge deal That's so heinous. Government should shut EBAY down and they can prove that problem has been corrected.
My first (and last, for now) restaurant meal post-shutdownA critic considers eating in restaurants while COVID-19 cases spike in California Mastro’s is the most overrated steakhouse. Ever since it was taken over by Landry’s they brought down the quality to an average chain restaurant. What was the point of writing this? You went out, apparently have no opinion worth sharing about the meal, then decided to not go out anymore? This reads like a Facebook post from an elderly relative. This the LA times food section. Jonathan Gold wrote for you. Do better 😋😋😋
CAA launches $100 million venture with Silicon Valley firm to finance post-pandemic projectsCAA and New Enterprise Associates formed Connect Ventures, which aims to support early-stage businesses centered in commerce, content and media. It's the latest move by agencies to diversify beyond the talent representation business. cool Are we gonna get sharknado 3 - the Covid edition ?
Silicon Valley economy remains strong 100 days into coronavirus, compared to other industriesWhile virtually every aspect of the economy has been hit hard during the pandemic, the tech Industry and its hub in Santa Clara County continue to fare...
What life is like as a Silicon Valley investor during a pandemic - Business InsiderBusiness Insider is a fast-growing business site with deep financial, media, tech, and other industry verticals. Launched in 2007, the site is now the largest business news site on the web. Who cares? So what Who gives a shit?
Tech CEOs turning to Black employees to solve diversity problems - Business InsiderBusiness Insider is a fast-growing business site with deep financial, media, tech, and other industry verticals. Launched in 2007, the site is now the largest business news site on the web.
What Trump's Immigration Restrictions Could Mean for the Economy - The Journal. - WSJ PodcastsThe Trump administration this week suspended a wide range of employment visas through the end of the year. WSJ's Michelle Hackman explains how the immigration restrictions could impact the American economy - from Silicon Valley to the Jersey Shore.