The Czech Republic and Poland are among the worst offenders of investor-state disputes worldwide
States are being sued over broken promises and contracts
EBASTIAN PAWLOWSKIused to gush about the economic potential of the Czech Republic and the wealth of Czech culture. The Swiss investor with Polish roots arrived in Prague in the early 1990s and became one of the top property developers in the Czech capital, then full of promise and excitement. He founded a popular private museum dedicated to Alphonse Mucha, a local art-nouveau master, and one to Franz Kafka, a Prague-born writer.
These days Mr Pawlowski is still a supporter of Czech arts, but would not invest another koruna in the country. He blames a kerfuffle over an investment in Benice, a Prague district where he bought land for residential development in 2007. This, Mr Pawlowski claims, was scuppered by local authorities, which in 2012 reversed zoning rules by court order.
Get our daily newsletterUpgrade your inbox and get our Daily Dispatch and Editor's Picks.Even now Mr Pawlowski still lacks permission to build the planned 800 flats. In 2017 he sued the Czech state at the World Bank’s International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes ( headtopics.com
ICSID) for $218m over a violation of the bilateral investment treaty (BIT) between Switzerland and the Czech and Slovak Federative Republic concluded in 1990, and still in force despite the country’s subsequent break-up.Mr Pawlowski is not the only investor who says he was stiffed by local or national governments in central and eastern Europe. Some of these legal tussles are part of the transition to a modern market economy. A lack of co-ordination between local and national authorities that make different promises is partly to blame. Increasingly, however, the region’s governments seem wilfully to ignore international rules.
Investors’ biggest concern is the subjugation of local courts by populist rulers. Andrej Babis, the Czech prime minister who is facing criminal charges over the misuse ofEUfunds, recently replaced his justice minister with a loyalist. Last week his Hungarian counterpart, Victor Orban, shelved a plan to create a parallel court system that would handle cases involving the state. But his earlier overhaul of the justice system has fuelled concerns about judicial independence. So have similar moves by Poland’s ruling Law and Justice party.
Investors rely onBITs to get a fair shake—those in central Europe more so than most. Of 942 investor-state disputes worldwide since 1987, a disproportionally high number involved post-communist countries that joined theEU15 years ago (see chart). The Czech Republic (38 cases) and Poland (30) are the worst offenders. By comparison, Germany and France, much bigger economies with more inward investments, have four cases between them.
Tales similar to Mr Pawlowski’s abound in the region. Invenergy, an American firm which invested 2.2bn zloty ($583m) in 11 wind farms in Poland in 2005, last year sued the Polish government for $700m in aUNcourt over cancelled power-purchase agreements. Poland’s courts sided with Invenergy but were ignored by state-controlled bodies. Another American investor, George Nussbaum, set up a billboard business in the 1990s that boomed until the Czech government banned billboards on highways because of traffic-safety concerns in 2012. This put an end to licensed roadside billboards but not those without legal permits, which are put up by some Czech firms. Mr Nussbaum is about to file a suit at the headtopics.com
ICSIDalleging a breach of the Czech-AmericanBIT.The British liquidator of New World Resources (NRW), an energy group, is threatening to lodge a complaint about the Czech government at theICSIDunder the Energy Charter Treaty, an international compact governing cross-border investments, over the insolvency and expropriation in 2017 of
OKDNRWused to own.In a case last year involving Achmea, a Dutch health-care company, and Slovakia the European Court of Justice ( Read more: The Economist »
Do you really think Westerners give a shit about Central or Eastern Europe? Why are millions & millions of them heading out as immigrants to the West with some parts of Briain being more Eastern European than their Native Eastern Europe! Investors’ biggest concern with the United States as well as central and eastern Europe is the subjugation of stacked courts by oligarch rulers
alllibertynews The Economist is upset sovereign countries are defending their national interests and demands countries submit to international capital. FakeNews and enemy of the people Rules of market that led to large differences between rich and poor?
Russia's pivot towards China could damage ties with Europe, Belgium's top official saysRussia's blossoming relationship with China could be a mixed blessing. Putin’s handshake is very official Russia has been pivoting to China for sometime, but it’s been challenging and awkward!
Trump's UK state visit fuels far-right in UK and EuropeIf Trump’s royal invitation to the UK was meant to stir political tensions, it seems the US president has done a good job. karsbreanne This asshole has been stirring political tensions in my household for the past 2.5 years.
Ford Europe Plans To Close British Engine PlantFord Motor Co’s loss-making European subsidiary said it is starting talks with unions about shutting an engine plant in Wales next year as part of its reconstruction plans to restore profitability. The factory, in Bridgend, Wales, employs about 1,700. Nice picture 🙂 So far our 2014 Nissan Leaf has run on pure electricity (from hydro and solar from our roof) for more than 110000 km. How about that for pure electric range...? EV ElectricVehicles electriccar elbil
Europe saved $8 billion on gas bill in 2018 due to LNG, reforms: IEAEurope saved $8 billion on its natural gas bill last year because surging U.S. s... there is no europe only a Europian Union....................
Why did Trump bring his children to Europe?Why did Trump bring his children with him on his recent overseas trip? The Washington Post notes that it's 'less clear how many other expenses would be incurred by taxpayers.' Why not? Because he’s afraid we’d lock them up while he’s away? Um... because he CAN