Dave Chappelle the Comedy Relic

After a decade of teaching Chappelle’s comedy to college students, a professor comes to terms with the fading relevance of the one-time GOAT.

10/22/2021 11:54:00 AM

'To my generation, watching Chappelle’s early-2000s specials felt like we were seeing someone turn into one of the greats in real time. To my students’ generation, those specials are relics.' mos_daf writes

After a decade of teaching Chappelle’s comedy to college students, a professor comes to terms with the fading relevance of the one-time GOAT.

Most of my students were born after the release of Chappelle’s 2000 special Killin’ Them Softly and were in preschool when his follow-up, For What It’s Worth, premiered four years later. When I introduce them to his early material, they are often surprised and impressed — by his ability to punch up, to speak truth to power, to focus his “attacks” on injustices and institutions with discernibly more power than he had. Also, he’s just funny. It’s Chappelle’s ability to respond to the realities of that time — to racism, sexism, policing, government mismanagement — with humor and precision that captivates them now like it captivated comedy audiences 20 years ago.

BTS Members Launch Individual Instagram Accounts Amid ‘Extended Period of Rest’ Announcement Christina Aguilera Delivers Dazzling Performance at 2021 People’s Choice Awards Test feeding plan in works for starving Florida manatees | AP News

We analyze in Killin’ Them Softly, for example, Chappelle’s clear articulation of racism and white privilege when it comes to policing. He tells a story about a white friend who gets pulled over by the police while drunk, high, and driving erratically and is released after explaining, “Sorry, officer. I … I didn’t know I couldn’t do that.” Students are always particularly drawn to Chappelle’s discussion of racial stereotypes. In this same special, he recounts the time a restaurant employee correctly guessed he was going to order chicken. “All these years, I thought I liked chicken because it was delicious. Turns out, I’m genetically predisposed to liking chicken!” He returns to this idea four years later in For What It’s Worth, explaining, “Just ’cause I eat chicken and watermelon, they think there’s something wrong with me. If you don’t like chicken and watermelon, something is wrong with you, motherfucker!” This is Chappelle at his best: Acknowledging everyday racism in the lives of Black people, revealing its absurdity without making light of the targets of such racism. These examples, even 20 years later, still hold their significance.

But what I’ve noticed in the past few years is that students are finding Chappelle less and less relevant. And this isn’t an inevitability due to his age; stand-ups older than Chappelle — comics like Tig Notaro, Leslie Jones, Marc Maron, and Paul F. Tompkins — continue to resonate with younger fans. To my generation, watching Chappelle’s early-2000s specials felt like we were seeing someone turn into one of the greats in real time. To my students’ generation, those specials are relics. To them, he is the Chappelle of 2021 — The Closer Chappelle. A man who’s so consumed with yelling at people on the internet that he forgot to be funny. What could be dismissed by longtime fans as a misstep is being considered by younger audiences as his modus operandi. Indeed, the bulk of Chappelle’s stand-up archive — what the public will have available to them to view and review — has been produced post-2016. The comedian he is now is the comedian he’s been most. headtopics.com

I’ve taught Chappelle in one context or another for the past ten years, but teaching him in the past five years has felt different. To younger audiences, he is out of step not only with the comedy of the moment but with the zeitgeist in general. He claims that he takes aim at everyone but focuses with laser precision on the most marginalized groups, specifically groups that push back on his work. He goes so far as to say that accusations that he’s now “punching down” — particularly at trans women — are his least favorite: “Punching down? What the fuck does that mean?” When I talk about punching down with my students, we talk about the negative tension created when a comedian with a certain amount of power targets someone with less. We talk about why we are disturbed by a rich, cisgender, heterosexual man making jokes about trans women. (A person who might criticize this as college-campus chatter might also remember that Chappelle has always been ubiquitous on campuses, in dorm rooms on Chappelle’s Show and on campus-comedy tours.)

But, of course, Chappelle knows exactly what “punching down” means, because he uses the question as a segue into a transphobic tirade in The Closer. What he’s really asking is: How can he punch down? In teaching Chappelle, it’s become increasingly important to address how a person can be marginalized while also marginalizing others. Comedy has often served as a defense mechanism or a survival tactic; it’s a way to take aim at a world that would destroy you otherwise, to articulate your selfhood when the world denies it. When you are used to having to scrap for a position as a comedian, it’s possible that when you’re finally empowered, you’re still so used to scrapping that you’re unwieldy. You might make mistakes. You might punch down.

Chappelle has said in previous acts and repeats in The Closer that “taking a man’s livelihood is akin to killing him,” in reference to DaBaby and Kevin Hart, both of whom lost major deals — a Lollapalooza performance and an Oscars host gig, respectively — in the wake of homophobic commentary, before moving on to other profitable opportunities. (It should be noted, however, that Hart voluntarily stepped down and refused to host the Oscars despite continued invitation from the show’s producers.) But he’s also talking about himself here, likening public critique and any imagined consequences he hasn’t actually experienced to a figurative loss of life. He does so in a moment when transgender and gender-nonconforming people are literally dying. In the most recent special, Chappelle attempts to once again leverage his “friendship” with trans woman and comedian Daphne Dorman as a sort of anti-apology for all the things he’s said. He can’t be transphobic because he has a trans woman friend, right?

Part of Chappelle’s early appeal was his stoner charm — he was the funniest pothead in the dorm. But in recent years that analogy has lost its savor, especially with students; for the new generation, his approach has been akin to an out-of-touch uncle who corners you at the holidays when you’re just trying to hang out with your cousins. He’s forgotten what my students know: that comedy exists in the terrain where boundaries are recognized and then transgressed without harming people who don’t deserve it. When boundaries are transgressed and people who don’t deserve it are harmed, it’s no longer comedy — it’s horror. headtopics.com

Tub Of Almonds Bought In Case Woman Becomes Completely Different Person Overnight Charlottesville’s Robert E. Lee statue to be melted down for new art Defense Department's review of Afghanistan drawdown begins 3 months after withdrawal

Last week, Netflix co-CEO Ted Sarandos sent out a memo to Netflix staff in support of Chappelle, saying, “While some employees disagree, we have a strong belief that content on screen doesn’t directly translate to real-world harm.” Sarandos later walked back his defense as an “oversimplification,” but it wasn’t just too simple; it was demonstrably false. In talking about the real-life implications of comedy, I refer my students to the tropes of the minstrel stage in the 19th century, which were used to support chattel slavery, recruit KKK members, and enact continuing violence against Black people. These racist caricatures demonstrated to eager white audiences that slavery was good for the enslaved because look at how happy their stand-in was on the stage. The performance was used to justify the status quo and erase the appearance of the violent reality only so that the violent reality could exist in secret. It was specifically intended to have real-life consequences. Chappelle — who left his multimillion-dollar contract with Comedy Central in 2005 — certainly knows that more acutely than most. He quit after dressing up as a Zip Coon minstrel in blackface. When he realized a white crew member was laughing at him and not with him, he concluded that the sketch was “socially irresponsible.”

Read more: New York Magazine »

Ralph Fiennes tells gentlemen spies' origin story in 'The King's Man'

Director Matthew Vaughn brings his third instalment of the 'Kingsman' spy action films to the big screen with a prequel movie starring Ralph Fiennes.

mos_daf yuvahallabol HPIndia BJP4India INCUttarakhand IYC PatrikaNews DainikBhaskar BangaloreTimes1 RCBTweets HPChannelNews hp HP_Newsroom NavbharatTimes ANI newyorklivetv CalSunday BBCHindi HPAmCentral GMA mos_daf I see, so now we are going to publish articles about how Dave Chappell isn’t with the times so deflect from his rise in popularity. You guys are THE joke.

mos_daf Chapelle was always trash. A poor man's Chris Rock. Kinda like Kanye's music. mos_daf Or history that your students can take a page from.

Netflix Employees Walk Out, Rally With Supporters For Trans CommunityStaff protested the company’s support of Dave Chappelle’s comedy special, which included transphobic material. Whatever happened to sticks and stones may break my bones but words will never hurt me? It's not transphobic.

Netflix employees stage walk-out over Dave Chappelle's comedy special The CloserDave Chappelle received a lot of backlash following the release of his comedy special The Closer where he made a lot of explicit jokes about transgender people He tried for 20 minutes of his very last special to make some kind of amends. That's a long time to try. His 6 special outro was to talk about it.

Netflix Employees Plan Walkout Amid Chappelle ControversyThe walkout begins at 10 a.m. in Los Angeles following the company’s release of a Dave Chappelle comedy special. Over Woke is a bad look!! I'm with Chapelle Reed hastings prob could not care less lol They’re jokes. Jokes. That’s all. Why can’t we laugh anymore? Life is depressing enough as it is.

Laugh Factory founder Jamie Masada calls on comedians to support Dave ChappelleDave Chappelle has found an ally in the Laugh Factory's founder, who's rallying the comedy community to support the embattled comedian. Dave has given me so many truths and laughs… I stand with Dave the comedy community

Netflix Employees Plan Walkout Amid Chappelle ControversyThe walkout begins at 10 a.m. in Los Angeles following the company’s release of a Dave Chappelle comedy special. BYE👋 There was more media covering it than employees walking out Ah Forbes .. it’s comedy

Leslie Jordan Conflicted Over Dave Chappelle Special and Netflix ControversyLeslie Jordan is visibly conflicted over the conflict raging at Netflix over Dave Chappelle's latest special. Listens to Eric Clapton though? We're not canceling Dave Chappelle .. stop trying.,,, Some of you should have met Bernie Mac 😕 Is he the dwarf who was trying on all of Snow White's clothes when she was asleep?