“We are here because our ancestors were extraordinary, and that is a point of pride. They fought their way out of all of those ropes and chains. We can be proud of that, and I think that’s what this work is about.” -TiyaMilesTAM Juneteenth
This week leads into the weekend celebration of Juneteenth , honoring the emancipation in 1865 of those who were enslaved in this country. The Black Feminist in Public series will highlight three scholars of slavery studies and Black women’s histories.Our third and final focus is Tiya Miles, professor of history at Harvard University and author of All That She Carried: The Journey of Ashley’s Sack, a Black Family Keepsake.
Ms.’s Janell Hobson.“The pile-up of traumatic moments and violated bodies and devastated lives [has] led to a sense of Black victimhood and an overwhelming picture of passivity and of abuse, which makes it challenging to look toward the future and feel that we can stand on the shoulders of our ancestors and be proud,” said Tiya Miles. (Kimberly P. Mitchell / USA TODAY NETWORK)
Our third and final focus is Tiya Miles, professor of history at Harvard University who studies the intersections of African American, Native American and women’s histories. She is the author of seven books—her most recent,All That She Carried: The Journey of Ashley’s Sack, a Black Family Keepsake
,exploring the history of slavery through a single object passed down through three generations of Black women in one family.Janell Hobson:Why do you think the history of slavery has been so contentious?TiyaMiles:Well, there was a concerted effort on the part of historians, intellectuals, enslavers, former enslavers, Southern politicians to tell us a different narrative about slavery, to try to write this chapter in U.S. history as one in which enslavers were paternalistic and benign, in which enslaved people really weren’t treated that badly, and in which we can embrace a narrative of American history that is progressive so that in the end, all is well because the country has been redeemed by virtue of the Civil Rights Movement, by virtue of the abolitionist movement even. It’s the ultimate expression of American virtue. headtopics.com
“There was a concerted effort … to tell us a different narrative about slavery, to try to write this chapter in U.S. history as one in which enslavers were paternalistic and benign … so that in the end, all is well because the country has been redeemed by virtue of the Civil Rights Movement.”
Hobson:How do you challenge that kind of master narrative?Miles:Earlier generations of historians thought to pull the curtains back and show just how deadly, just how brutal and exploitative enslavement was. To tell that kind of story, they had to show the suffering and the trauma that enslaved people experienced. However, that pile-up of traumatic moments and violated bodies and devastated lives have led to a sense of Black victimhood and an overwhelming picture of passivity and of abuse, which makes it challenging to look toward the future and feel that we can stand on the shoulders of our ancestors and be proud.
Hobson:Is that a real challenge for people of African descent? To learn to feel pride in this history instead of shame.Miles:It’s complicated. When I was in high school, I was attending a school that was predominantly white, and I remember being in the history classroom. When we reached our unit on slavery—a very short unit by the way—all eyes turned toward me, including the teacher’s. What I felt in that moment was a sense of shame, and I don’t think that’s uncommon. I’ve experienced that in my research when I have reached out to descendants of people who had been enslaved and whose stories I wanted to tell.
When I have conducted interviews with them, I have had people tell me, “No, my ancestor wasn’t enslaved,” and I’ve had to make difficult decisions on how to handle that. Because I have the documents, and I have the records that show how their ancestors were talking about their experience, and yet there was so much denial. “No, no. That’s not our past. Maybe it was some other people’s past, but our people were actually free.” headtopics.com
“I have had people tell me, ‘No, my ancestor wasn’t enslaved,’ and I’ve had to make difficult decisions on how to handle that. Because I have the documents, and I have the records that show how their ancestors were talking about their experience, and yet there was so much denial.”
Hobson:That denial is very telling, I think.Miles:I mean, there’s a deep investment in that, and I think the investment is partly a reaction to the shame of being told year after year, generation after generation, that you were the people who were stepped on. You were the people who were maimed and killed. You were the people who were raped. In fact, you are a
*result* of rape.These are the high stakes that exist in this research. We have to keep reinventing this work as we do it. We have to correct and counter-correct. I think every project that we take up is a new opportunity to course-correct toward what we need in the present moment, even while recognizing that we do have academic standards around the ways in which we conduct our research, around evidence, around how we construct our narratives, around what it is that we will say very clearly and firmly, and what it is that we will admit we’re not so certain about.
Hobson:Your comment reminds me of the research of Annette Gordon-Reed, who has a new book on Juneteenth but whoseaward-winning work on Sally Hemingsavoids calling her a “victim,” to capture all the nuances of her life. That’s a different conversation than just simply labeling President Thomas Jefferson, with whom she had children, a 19th century sexual predator in the vein of “R. Kelly”! headtopics.com
Miles:I think of the stages of grief. Some people did not want to have their heroic image of enlightenment hero Thomas Jefferson tarnished. To be frank, we—and by “we,” I’m speaking of African Americans, Black women. We also have aspects of our history and individuals in our history who we want to protect, who we don’t want to have sullied by certain kinds of revelations. So, we’re all emotionally and psychologically invested in historical conversations.
One of the things that I admire most about Annette Gordon-Reed’s representation of the Jefferson and Hemings relationship is exactly what you pointed out: I mean, she is the person who would not let this question rest, even when established Jefferson scholars were saying, “This is impossible. This is outrageous.” She kept pushing, and she found the evidence. She found the documentary evidence which coincided with the DNA evidence, and yet when she interpreted that evidence and when she articulated what it is that she had found, she chose the approach of taking some steps back from the heated center of the debate and saying, “Let’s look at the context. Let’s look at the complexity. Let’s look at Sally Hemings as a young person, yes, a teenager, but not an infant or a child who, in her time period, was at the age of coupling. Let’s look at her as a person who was thinking and observing and making decisions within a net of very complex relationships.”
In taking that approach, Annette Gordon-Reed perhaps didn’t give some people who were and are very angry about Jefferson’s role in that relationship the kind of portrayal that they wanted or the kind of interpretation they wanted, but I think she was being a responsible historian.
Hobson:That, of course, presents its own challenge: trying to look at history without interpreting it from your own present-day context.Miles:R. Kelly, and I have to say I have had my own days seething at Thomas Jefferson. I mean it’s just below the surface. You scratch it and I am furious with that man. And yet, we do need multiple voices. We need multiple opinions and takes on the issue. We need a prism-like approach because it’s a complex history and a complex situation and set of relationships. So, we have Annette Gordon-Reed’s very measured, very careful, and I think persuasive and powerful approach, which won’t satisfy everyone, and we also have people who are going to spell out the deeply exploitative nature of this kind of relationship. I think we need it all. We need multiple stories.
“I have had my own days seething at Thomas Jefferson … and yet, we do need multiple voices. We need multiple opinions and takes on the issue … because it’s a complex history and a complex situation and set of relationships.”Hobson:Speaking of multiple stories, let’s look at your new book on slave family history. How do you do that measured approach as well as take into account your own emotional reaction to this history? Could you say more also about how you started doing this work?
Miles:I started doing this this work on the study of slavery really back in college when Harriet Jacobs’sIncidents in the Life of a Slave Girlwas assigned in my introductory survey to African American literature.Hobson:That’s how I started my work in women’s studies too!
Miles:Yes. Jacobs is still signing us up, right?Hobson:Absolutely!Miles:So, I read that book, and I was floored. I was knocked off my feet by the book because it was so insightful and revealing, but also she was so vulnerable in it. I remember calling my grandmother and just telling her, “I don’t know what to do with this. How could they treat us this way?”
I was so close to my grandmother, and I still am even though she has passed, but also because Harriet Jacobs’s grandmother was so important to her and I really connected with that part. When I called my grandmother, that’s when she told me about her father having been enslaved. This is one of the misconceptions we have: that slavery was so far away. It doesn’t feel so far away to me because of that kind of emotional connection with the words that have been given to us by women like Jacobs and in my own family.
“This is one of the misconceptions we have: that slavery was so far away.”Hobson:It’s interesting that this history necessarily interweaves research and emotional connections.Miles:Yes, and this is how I started doing this work, when the world was reoriented for me after reading Harriet Jacobs’s narrative. I have been doing work on enslaved people and families, especially with Black women in the center of these stories for my whole career. In every book, there was a family, and there was a Black woman at the center of the story. When I couldn’t find a Black woman at the center of the story in terms of the evidence, I just kept broadening the circumference of the story until I could find her and interweave her history.
All That She Carriedis a part of that trajectory of wanting to see Black women’s experiences, wanting to see their words, wanting to interact with them, interact with their stories about their own lives, and to center their stories in our current discourse.
The particular way that I ended up writing about Ashley’s Sack is that I felt another gut punch when I saw this artifact at the National Museum of African American History and Culture. It was, for me, coming full circle to the first time I read Jacobs, because now in a different form and in a very compelling form and in a particularly tactile form, I was once again coming face-to-face with a very raw, beautiful, haunting expression of the experience of enslavement, which was being offered up by a Black woman who passed down a sack to her daughter and her daughter’s daughter. I knew I had to tell that story.
“When I couldn’t find a Black woman at the center of the story in terms of the evidence, I just kept broadening the circumference of the story until I could find her and interweave her history.”Hobson:I find it interesting how you were able to tell this story from this encounter with an artifact in a museum.
Miles:We wouldn’t have known about Rose, Ashley and Ruth if we were just wholly focused on archival records. This is a fundamental point about how looking elsewhere, searching widely, being creative expands what we might be able to say beyond what archives have stored within them. We have to do that. It is a necessity. We are still in recovery mode.
Hobson:In doing this work, how do we take pride in this history instead of shame?Miles:Honestly, we have nothing to be ashamed about. I look back at my 15-year-old self, maybe 16, and how I felt in that classroom and how my shoulders shrunk. No. No. They are the ones whose shoulders should’ve been shrinking in terms of the way in which that lesson was presented and the way in which we were interacting with it.
We are here because our ancestors were extraordinary, and that is a point of pride. They fought their way out of all of those ropes and chains. We can be proud of that, and I think that’s what this work is about. And like our ancestors, we too can face the very urgent and very frightening problems that we are seeing around us today. Out of unstable times, we have a woman like Rose, who refused to succumb to the logic that said someone else owned her daughter. She refused that, and we too can refuse all the terrible things that are going to come our way.Read more: Ms. Magazine »
Relocating a Commercial Spacecraft at the Space Station on This Week @NASA – July 23, 2021
Relocating a commercial spacecraft at the space station, while another one gets ready to launch to the station, and Perseverance prepares for a mission miles...
Black Feminist In Public: Jessica Marie Johnson on Slavery Studies and Black Sexual HistoriesThis week leads into the weekend celebration of Juneteenth , honoring the emancipation in 1865 of those who were enslaved in this country. The Black Feminist in Public series will highlight three scholars of slavery studies and Black women’s histories. First up: Jessica Marie Johnson, associate professor of history at John Hopkins University and author of Wicked Flesh: Black Women, Intimacy, and Freedom in the Atlantic World.
'Black girl magic at its\u00a0finest': Juneteenth pageants let women, girls be unapologetically BlackFor decades, beauty pageants have been criticized for objectifying women and for their lack of diversity, but organizers and contestants insist Juneteenth pageants are different. Bitcoin We are doing $5,000 challenge to 1BTC target in the next 4 weeks+. Started 1 week & days ago and already at $10,500. 🧑💻Send me a DM if you want to be a part of this, & for more details cryptyworld Is just a victory over the DNC racism. yeah yeah that's cool but tell me news everyone cares about, not your agenda.
For Black People In Corporate America, Juneteenth Is About More Than A Day Off“The opportunity with Juneteenth is treating it as an opportunity for reflection, education and acknowledgment.” brianne_garrett For all those who are new to this working from home Bitcoin trading options Here's a little tip: Get a trusted Bitcoin expert and stick to him Blakescott64 Invest and play at similar times each day. Because : In times of chaos, your investment is your anchor to success brianne_garrett No its not brianne_garrett I would hope so!
Candace Owens says Juneteenth gives Black people 'perpetual victim mentality'The right-winger attacked the new federal holiday commemorating the end of slavery after President Biden signed the bill officially recognizing it. Everyone supported MLK Jr and his fight until the Juneteenth bill. Good to know! Unfollow Perpetuating this ahistorical nutjob does not make you edgy or provocative. It makes you a RightWing nutjob publication.
Op-Ed: Everyone Should Acknowledge Juneteenth — But Don’t Celebrate It Unless You’re Black“As much as I want widespread recognition for Juneteenth as a holiday, I worry that people will take the reason for celebration and dilute it the way they’ve done with Martin Luther King Jr. Day.”
For Black People In Corporate America, Juneteenth Is About More Than A Day Off“The opportunity with Juneteenth is treating it as an opportunity for reflection, education and acknowledgment.” The curse is over!!!! 😘🙌🏾 1619-2019 Are you in need of 3D PRODUCT ANIMATION VIDEO TO ENHANCE YOUR BUSINESS AND SERVICES.... We can help out... Reach Out to us Today! business USAvMEX USA 3D 3Danimation 3dmodeling 3dxanimation animation animatorvsanimation china canda Ukraine Yeah it’ll be awesome but yet odd to be off work oh well rather get paid for being off than to be off and not get paid. Why’d government won’t just pay us cash 💵 money