Are space scientists ready for Starship—the biggest rocket ever?

8/11/2022 10:30:00 PM

SpaceX’s behemoth could upend research with its immense capacity and low costs

When Starship makes its first orbital launch attempt, many researchers will be watching, waiting to see whether that giant silvery rocket is a vision of space science’s future, or a mirage. LongReads

SpaceX’s behemoth could upend research with its immense capacity and low costs

Tankers refuel ship and return to Earth.Get the ad-free experience for life The rocket then ascends to orbit using its seven Archimedes Engines, which cut out once it reaches deployment altitude.the subject of multiple criminal investigations.detected the world in question around the adolescent star AS 209 using the Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array in Chile.

4 Refueled ship travels to Mars.5 Ship refueled using martian resources.The animation transitions to space to show the second stage flying off as the rocket reorients and closes its fairing for the return trip.6 Ship returns directly to Earth.But Schorsch said determining what the warrant was about was beyond what he was capable of in the frantic moments between confirming the news and tweeting it.V.One look at the animation gives the impression that the animation was largely inspired by footage of the Starship prototype tests.Altounian/ Science Pierre Lionnet, a space economist at Eurospace, an industry trade group, is skeptical SpaceX can achieve such a low price point.6 million years old, but because of how close it is to the Earth.

It may not correctly account for the costs of developing and building the rocket, for example.The way the central engine fires up to bring the rocket’s tail around for a landing is highly reminiscent of the “belly-flop maneuver” SpaceX performed.I talk with a lot of people, I do podcasts, I lay out, you know, snarky tweets and things like that.“When I look at Starship, I’m looking at what seems to be a very expensive device.” To achieve profitability with such high capital costs, SpaceX will have to attain its ambitious launch rates, which means it will need paying customers to soak up all that cargo capacity.Once complete, the Neutron rocket will stand 40 meters (131 ft) tall and measure 7 meters (23 ft) in diameter.SpaceX hopes to develop new markets in space mining, tourism, or other activities not yet dreamed of, but Lionnet is not so sure the heavy lifter will whet that appetite all by itself." Allison Davis / Via allisonlynnphotography.“If you’re vegetarian, and I’m offering you a burger, I can offer it at the cheapest possible price, and you don’t eat it.4 ft) diameter fairing will give it an impressive payload capacity for a medium-lift rocket, allowing it to accomplish multiple mission profiles – from satellite deployment and deep-space missions to human spaceflight.But how exactly do we go about proving the existence of an exoplanet from which we barely have a signal? Well, that’s where the James Webb space telescope comes into play.

” The debate will soon graduate beyond the theoretical.In May 2021, after several spectacularly explosive failures, a Starship upper stage flew 10 kilometers up into the atmosphere.3 million pound-force (lbf) of lift-off thrust – 7,530 kN (1,640,000 lbf) of peak thrust – and payload capacity of 13,000 kg (lbs) to Low Earth Orbit (LEO).Schorsch thought it would be about a local candidate the former president would endorse or an event he'd be attending.After landing, it briefly caught fire, but the company deemed the suborbital flight a success.Since then, SpaceX has built out Starbase, constructing a launch tower that can catch returning boosters with two robotic arms the company calls “chopsticks.This allows for a fully-reusable rocket and fairing design, which SpaceX has also experimented with by making their.” It has refined its rocket assembly line, which can now build four Raptor engines per week."So my mind just races at that point, and I had to be polite to my friend who I was talking to and get them off the phone.

And in June, FAA gave SpaceX approval to launch from Starbase, provided it takes steps to minimize the impact on the environment.At the February event, Musk said he was confident Starship would make its first orbital attempt this year.For Musk, the sci-fi dreams are tantalizingly within reach.It's still unclear what the warrant was for, but.“Let’s make this real!” he exhorted the crowd, pumping his fists.Science has mostly been an afterthought for Musk.

But Heldmann has been surprised that, for many planetary scientists, Starship has also been an afterthought.In 2020, she and a team of researchers and industry insiders submitted a white paper touting the benefits of Starship to the “decadal survey” in planetary science, an influential community exercise that helps NASA and Congress set long-term priorities.“It’s a good time to try and get this idea in the consciousness of others,” she says.Heldmann and her colleagues suggested NASA create a dedicated funding line for missions relying on Starship.In 2021, workers stacked a Starship upper stage on a Super Heavy booster.

SpaceX The survey embraced the ideas.In its April report, the survey committee explicitly mentioned Starship and cited ideas in Heldmann’s paper.The committee recommended a funding line relevant to Starship’s specs and said NASA should plan to capitalize on the rocket’s potential.“Both cargo and crew flights to Mars offer significant potential science opportunities,” the committee said.The benefits wouldn’t be limited to the Moon and Mars, points out Daniel Baker, director of the Laboratory for Atmospheric and Space Physics at the University of Colorado, Boulder.

For instance, Mercury, with its weak gravity, has been a tough target because of the extra fuel required to slow a spacecraft enough to get into orbit; the Sun’s heat is another problem.But Starship wouldn’t mind the big gas tank or the sunshade needed to keep the spacecraft from melting.Baker also envisions faster missions to the outer planets that don’t require time-consuming gravitational assists from other planets.Even farther afield, Interstellar Probe, a proposed mission to follow in the footsteps of NASA’s famed Voyager mission , could carry more capable instruments aboard Starship—and get a faster ride to interstellar space.Some astronomers also have Starship in their eyes.

“There’s no way to talk about it without resorting to cliches, but ‘best rocket engine ever,’ probably, by most metrics,” says David Rubin, a cosmologist at the University of Hawaii, Manoa.He wonders how much simpler the $10 billion James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) might have been if its 6.5-meter-wide segmented mirror hadn’t had to fold up to fit on its rocket.Engineers could have built a monolithic mirror and launched it as is within the 9-meter-wide Starship fairing, which encloses a volume about half as big as a hot air balloon.Rubin also dreams of using Starship to construct a giant telescope—say 30 meters—in space.

Limbed robots could precisely lay down mirror segments on a scaffolding, forming a giant mirror that could pick out the universe’s first galaxies and look for signs of life in the atmospheres of Earth-like exoplanets.“The science gains scale really quickly as you build larger and larger telescopes,” Rubin says.If thousands and thousands of tons are going to orbit, someone’s going to figure out how to put a telescope up there without NASA.David Rubin University of Hawaii, Manoa Not all astronomers are fans of SpaceX, which has already launched nearly 3000 of its Starlink internet satellites into low orbits, where sunlight glinting off them leaves streaks on the cameras of ground-based telescopes.The problems could multiply with Starship, which could launch hundreds of Starlinks at a time, enabling the company to build its planned constellation of up to 42,000 satellites even faster.

SpaceX now equips the satellites with “sunshades” to reduce the reflective glare, but astronomers are still worried.“Making access to space and Earth orbit easier has a lot of benefits,” says Meredith Rawls, an astronomer at the University of Washington, Seattle, and a member of an International Astronomical Union center set up to mitigate satellite interference.“But we need to make sure that we’re doing it in a mindful way and not just having it be a Wild West disaster.” As another reality check for the dreamers, Lionnet points out that discounted rides will only reduce the cost of missions by so much.For major scientific projects, Lionnet says, launch costs are usually between just 5% and 10% of the total price tag.

For JWST, the fraction was even smaller.The typical cost for a ride on an Ariane 5 rocket, JWST’s launcher, is about $175 million, just 2% of the mission’s total price tag.“A complex telescope will still be a complex telescope,” Lionnet says.But cheaper launches could allow the probes themselves to be cheaper, with less need for space-rated parts that save on weight or bulk.With Starship, planetary scientists wanting to outfit a rover with a spectrometer could just buy one on the internet.

Astronomers could use a glass mirror instead of a featherweight beryllium one, like JWST’s.And, Rubin says, “You should just be able to shield your way into radiation hardness,” rather than soldering circuits out of specialized materials.Thousands of hexagonal heat tiles will keep Starship from burning up when it reenters Earth’s atmosphere.Reginald Mathalone/NurPhoto/AP Earth-observation researchers have already been down that road.For many years, remote sensing satellites were big and pricey—little different from JWST, says Aravind Ravichandran, founder of the spaceindustry consultancy TerraWatch Space.

But about a decade ago came the “small satellite” revolution: Researchers shrank and standardized equipment and took advantage of rideshares on relatively cheap Falcon 9 launches and other small rockets.Suddenly, university students were sending shoebox-size CubeSats to space.Using cheap cameras and consumer electronics, the company Planet built up a fleet of about 200 small satellites that gather daily images of all of Earth’s land.Ravichandran sees Starship making it easier to assemble ever bigger fleets—enough eyes on the planet to revisit a given spot multiple times an hour, rather than every few hours, days, or weeks.“Why can’t you do every 5 minutes? Every 10 minutes?” Ravichandran asks.

Imagine, he says, what that kind of revisit rate might do for, say, tracking wildfires or floods.Handmer, who now works as a clean-energy entrepreneur, wants astronomers and planetary scientists to adopt this sort of bold thinking.Instead of a 30-meter telescope, why not a 1000-meter one? Why not mass-produce probes that could survey dozens of asteroids? Why not fly by all the outer planets in the next decade? Or land on most planets annually? In Handmer’s view, the problem is partly cultural: NASA engineers try to get everything right on the first try, at all costs—the vastly expensive, long-delayed JWST being a prime example.“It’s kind of like a medieval cathedral,” he says, of such flagship missions.To exploit Starship’s immense capacity, Handmer estimates NASA will need to make 100 times as much stuff for a fraction of the usual cost.

It will need to be a fast-fashion factory, not a boutique.But having worked at JPL, Handmer isn’t necessarily hopeful that will happen.“It was just not set up to mass-produce anything,” he says.Rubin says NASA centers could get left behind by nimbler companies, or privately funded scientists.“If thousands and thousands of tons are going to orbit, someone’s going to figure out how to put a telescope up there without NASA,” he says.

Astrobotic, which calls itself a “lunar logistics company,” has sprung up with this sort of business model.It plans to send landers and rovers to the Moon, carrying instruments for paying customers.Robert Manning, JPL’s chief engineer, doesn’t think the facility is quite so resistant to change.But he also questions Handmer’s vision of cheap, mass-produced probes.The equipment used at the scientific frontier is rarely standard.

Every mission, with its fresh targets and questions, requires innovation.And it’s hard to take risks as a public agency, Manning says.“We have an obligation to make sure that we are not wasteful of taxpayers’ dollars,” he says.“We can’t throw things to space frivolously and say, ‘Well, if it doesn’t work, let’s build another one.’” In 1992, then–NASA Administrator Daniel Goldin pushed the agency to pursue a “faster, better, cheaper” approach—a mantra that was discarded later in the decade after high-profile losses of the Mars Climate Orbiter and Mars Polar Lander.

If a faster, better, cheaper culture is to return, Manning says both NASA and Congress will have to bless the risk-taking—and stand up for it when things go wrong.“It’s going to be difficult to politically communicate that that’s OK for us to try it out,” Manning says.But assuming all those issues worked themselves out, he acknowledges that frequent, low-cost, high-mass-and-volume launches could provide “an incredible opportunity for us to change how we get things done and be willing to take more risks.” JPL has already been thinking about it, he says—for example, considering how to incorporate standardized, lower cost components in NASA’s custom deep-space missions.There’s a major asterisk on the rocket revolution that Starship heralds.

“We haven’t been able to act on it yet,” Manning says, “because it’s not true yet.” When Starship makes its first orbital launch attempt, many researchers will be watching, waiting to see whether that giant silvery rocket is a vision of space science’s future, or a mirage.About the author.

Read more:
News from Science »
Loading news...
Failed to load news.

ScienceVisuals Hahaha. Even in rockets, Goverment always increases cost and lowers quality. ScienceVisuals StopHazaraGenocide For the female students killed in the Kaj educational center in Kabul, Afghanistan. StopHazaraGenocide ScienceVisuals StopHazaraGenocide be our voice ScienceVisuals Goverment of Iran is attacking to our talented Sharif university student, arresting und shooting them, Please be our voice. 🆘️Iran MahsaAmini

ScienceVisuals ScienceVisuals مهسا امینی ScienceVisuals MahsaAmini ScienceVisuals MahsaAmini ScienceVisuals The iranian people been cut off from the internet while world leaders are meeting at the united nations.please be their voiceMahsaAmini ScienceVisuals The iranian people been cut off from the internet while world leaders are meeting at the united nations.please be their voiceMahsaAmini

ScienceVisuals nb

Hazegrayart Shows how Rocket Lab's Reusable Neutron Rocket Could WorkA new animation shows what Rocket Lab's totally-reusable rocket will look like when it starts sending satellites to space.

ScienceVisuals tell me how this ancient stone was cut ScienceVisuals mahsa_amini ScienceVisuals The iranian people been cut off from the internet while world leaders are meeting at the united nations.please be their voicemahsa_amini ScienceVisuals Movex is a MOVE to EARN X Project Movex Fairlaunch Not just walking or running! Win in every move! win even by turning to the side while sleeping!

ScienceVisuals If you want to go on Mars cause it's too late you're just a f. Liar. It's not too late , a plan to go back without launching people in the sky is possible. Stop lying for profits b. ScienceVisuals Heavy lifter cause trouble to attraction when use low altitudes. Thx for the mess. ScienceVisuals 🙄 Dont let the politicians off the planet, they destroyed the planet they should have to go down with the ship

ScienceVisuals If you need to populate Mars I don't think something that Big will need a condom.... ScienceVisuals Starship is definitely a game-changing rocket and this is the competition the industry needed to improve its technology and invest in innovation. ScienceVisuals Follow me

We Spoke To The Local Florida Reporter Who Got The Scoop On The FBI Raid At Mar-A-Lago'This was 100% the biggest scoop that I probably will ever get.'

ScienceVisuals Who can pause an explosion? ScienceVisuals All the time in the universe. Be at peace. ScienceVisuals Friends Take a glance at that picture? In the 1st second of the 'bang' LOOK at the distance traveled. Then? Notice the distance traveled after 3 minutes? After 300 thousand years? After 1 thousand million years? Do you see it? Slowing Wayyyy down... Then? Stop

ScienceVisuals wouldnt it be cheaper to keep the ship in orbit and haul the payload and fuel to the ship after its first return to earth? ScienceVisuals Starship gonna to the Mars!!!👍 ScienceVisuals Wow ScienceVisuals Infographic is missing booster 2’s return to Earth ScienceVisuals Why do elon fanboys always create infographics with hilariously bad and blatantly made up cost figures?

ScienceVisuals 10 dollars? wtf?XD ScienceVisuals 10 dollar 😂

New exoplanet discovery may challenge everything we know about planetary formationScientists may have discovered the youngest exoplanet ever detected, but we'll need James Webb to actually prove the planet's existence.

ScienceVisuals 100 tons is like what? Three semi trailers? ScienceVisuals oh, I see it now. a tanker ScienceVisuals What's going on at the third stage? Do those two join together ScienceVisuals Is this cost/kg calculated including reusability of like 100 flights? ScienceVisuals Would Starship be able to lift itself off the surface of Mars without a Booster?

ScienceVisuals Blah I've seen it on star trek ScienceVisuals That will cost some hard $$$ ScienceVisuals Os foguetes são uma sucata arcaica. Vocês precisam evoluir. ScienceVisuals God bless. ScienceVisuals Why does it not need refueling on the return trip? Does it have to do with the energy required to escape earth vs. mars?

Scientist Admits ‘Space Telescope Image’ Actually Slice Of ChorizoA prominent French scientist has apologized after tweeting a photo of a slice of chorizo that he claimed was a deep-space image of a “distant star” snapped by the James Webb Telescope. What do you think? Slice? I thought it was kielbasa. Oh we need the image! Snag one from NASA ?

ScienceVisuals Lol. They can't even radio right. How safe could a rocket be? Tesla Model X - XM favorites ScienceVisuals ScienceVisuals Best dickpic ever. ScienceVisuals 5 ? ZickyX ScienceVisuals 🖤🖤🖤🖤🖤🖤🖤💛 ScienceVisuals This does not look like an Uber cool car that flys... ScienceVisuals What are those Martian Resources ?

ScienceVisuals Wouldn't it be more economical to launch from the moon, ideally via electromagnetic rail launch? ScienceVisuals I am not a rocket scientist but don't you also need the big re-usable tube thing to carry enough fuel to take off from mars to get back to earth? And does it really use electricity to re-fuel?

ScienceVisuals Didn't NASA really know how to built cheaper? What a good business. Wao

'Gigantic jet' that shot into space may be the most powerful lightning bolt ever detectedThis lightning bolt over Oklahoma was one of the rarest and most powerful on Earth.

ScienceVisuals இன்னும் அங்கேயே தேடு ScienceVisuals This why we need to put people on the moon n Mar people who are willing to do the work ScienceVisuals Fuel is not the issue technology is …is not safe for human to survive in space because too many unknown factors ScienceVisuals Windows os it’s a version of Unix and also Apple too

ScienceVisuals Because NASA still got satellite they created in the 1980 flying in space THIS HOW THEY FOUND OUT ABOUT THE INTERNET WE HAVE TODAY NASA are still using IBM software known as Unix Unix is the internet we use everyday ScienceVisuals NASA developed technology by scratch. I don't know about SpaceX

ScienceVisuals Is this a penis thing? ScienceVisuals Name it 'Jefferson' please ScienceVisuals ✅ ScienceVisuals ...

Hulu Says ‘Prey’ Is Its Biggest Movie or TV Series Premiere EverPreyMovie set a Hulu record, notching the most viewing hours ever in its first three days. That means the 'Predator' film had a bigger aggregate viewing-time total than “The Kardashians,” which Hulu said was its biggest TV series premiere in April. Good to see something respectable getting the viewing figures instead of gutter scraping, IQ-insulting garbage TV content. Bon film PreyMovie formidables acteurs et actrices 👏😀🇨🇵

ScienceVisuals ElonMuskForPresident ScienceVisuals Wanting Eron Musk to build a flying saucer, I did some research. It has a law of transformation of matter. Sphere of influence. It uses plasma for energy. ScienceVisuals Been watching rocket launches All life. This one will be amazing to watch. ScienceVisuals Parece que la NASA ha estado inflando los costos 🤔🤔🤫🤫🤑🤑👽👽🦎🦎🚀🚀

ScienceVisuals Wow! New inventions are always help to grow fast. ScienceVisuals I will approve rejected instagram shop and facebook shop and fix all issues 新信長公記 MVเหล่ท่อ 虹5thNT_day2 amici22 valorantchampions2022 CONTACT ME THANKS, DAVID. ScienceVisuals Optimization of cost/kg 👀 Starship is a game changer of Space Age era proportions.

ScienceVisuals Will there be any centrifugal inside the craft to create artificial gravity for the long journey to mars ? ScienceVisuals That's believable, brilliant ScienceVisuals 🌻My salutations to all the scientists and engineers of the technical department of the country. 🌻Dear Sir I don't know whether you guys will believe me or not 🌻What is Dream... this is such a secret question which has not been tracked till date.

ScienceVisuals But useless trying to go to Mars is stupid and s huge waste of resources ScienceVisuals And the cheapest too ScienceVisuals I hope to be there to observe starship transporting humans to Mars ScienceVisuals Many people may not like Musk for whatever superficial reasons...but there is simply no denying the work he is doing to accelerate our progress in the fields of science and space travel...

ScienceVisuals Please be our voice! MahsaAmini, the 22yo who was arrested and beaten by the 'Islamic Moral Security Gestapo' of Iran 's Islamic Republic, passed away a few hours ago. She was arrested for 'improper hijab!' مهسا_امینی Mahsa_Amini ScienceVisuals The biggest point here… why the shit is SLS still a thing when Falcon 9 is 95% cheaper to operate?

ScienceVisuals Still can’t leave earth’s orbit. ScienceVisuals Great Rocket🚀🚀 ScienceVisuals Why does it say debut 2022 when it hasnt flown yet? ScienceVisuals 👏🥰

ScienceVisuals Falcon Heavy should have been here in this illustration instead of Falcon 9 ScienceVisuals The heaviest of the heavy lifters ScienceVisuals SLS is a joke when it comes to cost per KG ScienceVisuals how on earth is SLS 58k/kg thats 10x the price of Saturn 5 which was 60 yrs ago. unreal

ScienceVisuals DASAR HUKUM PRESIDENTIAL THRESHOLD SEJAK 2004 ScienceVisuals The rocket engine abstract and design was done over 50 years ago. It could not have been done without developing a turbopump capable of countering LOX flow, with hot methane flow. The design was put in the closet by both governments. Until the engine guys at SpaceX attempted it.

ScienceVisuals Make it as big as it needs to be,we need to explore space ScienceVisuals Capitalism. Liberals want socialism. Progress like this doesn't work under socialism ScienceVisuals Let's coat it in Graphene monolayer! (Paint sample from my Wrangler) ScienceVisuals WR4NYGov video on this soon and how it can disrupt industries not just space travel.

ScienceVisuals Why not use Mars fuel on Earth? ScienceVisuals SpaceX is gonna kill it, all their Aerospace Engineers and employees are wicked. ScienceVisuals This is so much misinformation and befuddling the name of science - unbelievable. ScienceVisuals How does Elon get more money from the goverment? Anyway possible

ScienceVisuals TAKE MUSK TO MARS ScienceVisuals When I see these rockets, I can't avoid myself thinking of the scientist designing these rockets if they had erection problems. ScienceVisuals elonmusk Expel the emissions, collect the excrement and catalyze into an end product that can be used instead of discarded. Bigger is not better.. Bigger is heavier, heavier means more fuel less efficiency.

ScienceVisuals I’m Ready ScienceVisuals I hope so. It's going to change everything. But first it has to fly come back and land and be ready shortly after that to do it again and again 🤠 ScienceVisuals The god said : O company of the jinn and mankind, if you are able to pass from the regions of the heavens and the earth, then flashes of fire and copper will be sent upon you, and you will not be victorious

ScienceVisuals قال تعالى:وَجَعَلْنَا السَّمَاءَ سَقْفًا مَحْفُوظًا وَهُمْ عَنْ آَيَاتِهَا مُعْرِضُونَ . من سورة الأنبياء- آية (32) ScienceVisuals Se investir primeiro em um Hotel Órbital turístico, o progresso acelerará múltiplas vezes ScienceVisuals Tem que desenhar o programa espacial brasileiro... LulaOficial ...

ScienceVisuals $10/kg is speculation. Maybe eventually but will be nothing close to that for a while. Dev costs to amortize, etc. ScienceVisuals 😆😆😆 ScienceVisuals SaveToNotion Thread ScienceVisuals will this be used for sata lite or for weapons Everything can be misused ScienceVisuals 이제 달에 갈 시간이 가까이온듯, 우선 지구 한바퀴 돌고 착륙하는 실험성공을 몇번하고 달에 착륙시켜야지. 그다음에 달에서 출발해서 지구까지 돌아오는것을 해야할 차례지. 무조건 도전해야해. 실패를 두려워하면 안돼. 무조건가야해. 실패해도 무조건 해야해.

ScienceVisuals Vertical blimps ScienceVisuals So what. This rocket stuff is so meaningless.

ScienceVisuals Join us ScienceVisuals So according to this chart it's gonna cost under $1k for a space burial Allow this washbasin to enter ScienceVisuals SpaceX is much love! ScienceVisuals Block-1 which is used in ArtemisLaunch cost/kg is the reason why Spacex is the future of space travel and cargo launches 🚀

NewsfromScience I hope grace slick has been involved… ScienceVisuals That's correct? 58,000$/Kg Vs 10$/Kg? Don't know, Rick....