Malka Leifer's case is shaking the Australian Jewish community's faith in Israel | Michael Visontay
The message has been clear: politicians don’t treat allegations of sexual child abuse seriously
Our disgust goes beyond the violation and lifelong emotional scars, to the nature of betrayal. The very people entrusted with protecting the most vulnerable have become the source of their worst nightmares. The royal commission highlighted the cultures of denial, concealment and enabling that allowed perpetrators to keep abusing and escape justice.
This is perhaps why the Malka Leifer case, more than any other issue, has shaken the Australian Jewish community’s faith in Israel’s commitment to justice and made it more permissible to openly criticise the government. This is no small change.Over the years the community leadership has been unwavering in its support of Israel, regardless of its government’s actions. While the Palestinian occupation has increasingly stirred feelings of doubt, there has been an implicit acceptance by the heartland of Australian Jewry that the conflict is intractable, everyone’s hands are dirty and that Israeli governments should not be judged any more harshly than others around the world.
But Leifer’s case is different. It’s personal, we know the alleged victims, she ran away. The Israeli government, or at least the health minister, has demonstrated its contempt for the most basic of human injustices – the alleged assault of young children. More than that, its health minister has been charged with interfering on behalf of Leifer.
The former principal of Melbourne’s ultra-Orthodox Adass Israel school faces extradition to Australia on 74 charges of sexually assaulting female students during her time as principal. The school management helped spirit her to Israel in 2008.Leifer’s lawyers claim she suffers from paralysing anxiety and is mentally unfit to face court; yet despite clear-cut video evidence that she is going about her life as normal, judge after judge has been unable to rule that she is fit to be extradited, and face Australian justice. Her case has dragged on for five years, involved 57 hearings and more than 30 psychiatrists.
Some of Leifer’s alleged victims, led by the Melbourne woman Dassi Erlich and her sisters, Nicole Meyer and Elly Sapper, have mounted a courageous campaign to have her extradited. Their advocacy has given the case a high profile within the local Jewish community.
This year that pressure intensified when the Israeli health minister, Yaacov Litzman, also an ultra-Orthodox Jew, was charged with pressuring psychiatrists to alter their reports to find Leifer was mentally unfit to stand. The government was accused of being complicit in the cover-up; Leifer’s case grew into a major Israeli news story.
The images of Malka Leifer, looking dull and downcast to avert the media’s gaze, Dassi Erlich speaking defiantly, and now the white-bearded Litzman, still the heath minister, have become commonplace in Jewish social discourse.Last week the farce reached a new low when an Israeli judge allowed Leifer to be released on bail from house arrest to stay with her sister, pending the next hearing in December.
Collectively, these revelations have left Australian Jews disillusioned on a number of levels. Firstly, with the integrity of Israel’s justice system and the elected politicians who administer it. The message has been clear: they don’t care, they don’t treat allegations of sexual child abuse seriously.
• Sign up to receive the top stories from Guardian Australia every morningSecondly, with the status of ultra-Orthodox (Haredi) Jews. For many years, even as the Haredim have become more involved in government, many secular Jews held that although their values were out of touch with modern life, they should be accepted as part of the Jewish social fabric. But the deceit that enabled Leifer to allegedly abuse in the first place, then flee, and receive support from a government minister, has corroded that tolerance. Loyalty cannot trump integrity.
Private disquiet has been given public voice through the Zionist Federation of Australia, the national custodian of the relationship between Australian Jews and Israel. The ZFA has become outspoken in its criticism of the Leifer case, as has the Australian Israel Jewish Affairs Council, sending a strong signal to other Jewish community groups, including fundraising organisations.
Among a welter of protests from Australian politicians, Dave Sharma, the former ambassador to Israel who is now the Liberal member for the eastern Sydney seat of Wentworth, said the decision “defies explanation”. Sharma was strongly supported by Jewish community leaders in this year’s federal election, and his comment echoed the depth of disappointment in Jewish circles.
In the wake of last week’s bail verdict, the Israeli newspaper Haaretz reported that, according to diplomatic sources, the case could cause a serious rift in Israel-Australia relations and prompt sections of the Australian Jewish community to consider cutting off donations.
While it is too soon to gauge whether either of these allegations will be borne out, there is now a fresh climate for Australian Jewish fundraising groups to review their priorities and decisions, both in terms of speakers and where their fundraising dollars are targeted.
The longer Malka Leifer remains in Israel, the louder the misgivings will become. Read more: The Guardian »
The Green Recovery | The Guardian
Latest The Green Recovery news, comment and analysis from the Guardian, the world's leading liberal voice
Destruction of innocence seems to be agenda 1 - Elite conspiracy TruthExposed graphicnovel The power and influence of Israel. No longer about Palestinians alone. When is the world going to stand up to such injustices and suffering? Actually DO SOMETHING to save the planet and save $2000 a year on gas with this e-bike!
Shaken baby cases 'tip of the iceberg'Hundreds of infants die from being shaken but experts 'don't know the full scale of the problem'. Khashoggi 😢 Who are these beasts that do this, not normal people surely?
The Silver Lake at Hackney Empire was a larger than life performance that could hardly be more topical - reviewAll the voices in this production are big, finds Michael Church, with Pasha Selim’s roars of frustrated rage shaking the rafters Perfect for an office run (and back!). Save $2000 on fuel every year with an e-bike!
Cream drummer Ginger Baker dies aged 80One of rock's most influential musicians, he played with Cream, Blind Faith and Public Image Ltd. RIP Noooooooo 😭 I hope he's gone to The White Room.
Joy Morgan: human remains found in search for studentDiscovery comes two months after Shohfah-El Israel was jailed for her murder Prayers for her family
Gastro outbreak strikes more than 100 passengers on Sydney to Perth trainAustralian health authorities say they are working with Indian Pacific operator to control norovirus outbreak Horror/comedy stuck on a train everyone has diarhea, yet so little toilets. Gross Having ridden this train I can only imagine the horror. They may as well just burn the train and buy a new one.
Sudden deaths of hundreds of migrant workers in Qatar not investigatedExclusive: in majority of cases, authorities do not perform postmortems, despite recommendations from regime’s lawyers Probably the DohaWorldChampionships says it all . Athletics in the middle of a gulf summer . Corruption and Oil bucks . I have been writing about this for two years. Since a 60 minute show on how the stadiums were built. This was space labor and unconscionable acts against humanity. FIFAWorldCup should cancel and move this tournament. There must be consequences to these human rights abuses Tamara__Barnett There were some discussions to boycott the games or in some levels businesses with there , but well the dirty truth is that money is more important that human life these days.