Low Covid vaccination rates among Māori reflect practical barriers – but they also have good reason to distrust the government
over the weekend, smashing the government’s goal and lifting Auckland’s vaccination rate to just shy of 90%. But underneath that success, shocking inequities remain. The vaccination rate for Pacific peoples still lags the rate for Pākehā, or European New Zealanders, and the Māori rate lags further still. Only 63% of
Māorihave had their first shot. For Pākehā, it’s 84%. This is partly due to geography. If you inspect the government’s vaccination map, a national register laying out every vaccine centre in New Zealand, you might notice something startling: there are barely any vaccine centres in rural Māori communities. This essay asks why.
The Tasman Mill in Kawerau once ensured the town’s residents enjoyed one of the highest living standards in the world.Photograph: Michael BradleyA town like few othersIn Kawerau’s prime, from the early 1950s to the late 1980s, when the Tasman pulp and paper mill was responsible for producing 20% of New Zealand’s exports, the hall was home to travelling plays, a “picture theatre” screening the latest foreign films, and concerts classic and popular. This is where the country’s chief crooner, Sir John Rowles, who would go on to a concert residency in Las Vegas, picked up his craft performing for the American mill managers, who made their mansions on “Knob Hill”. headtopics.com
Kawerau was a town like few others. The population of only 8,000 also had access to a full-service supermarket – a consumer luxury in the mid-20th century – a department store (quite the posh amenity), a video game parlour, and even competing cosmopolitan clubs.
Underpinning this prosperity was a government guarantee: import controls, industrial subsidies, and competition policy would ensure the Tasman Mill maintained an effective domestic monopoly. With that lucrative corner of the pulp and paper market the town’s residents would enjoy one of the highest standards of living in the world. But in return for this generosity the local hapū (sub-tribe) had to make three agreements. First, that they would sell the land above their ancient geothermal fields, providing the industrial zone where the mill sits, and the electricity to power it. Second, they would consent to the mill accessing the crystal clear Tarawera river. Pulp and paper productions requires fresh water by the tonnage. And third, that they would help provide the manpower to fell and process the timber from the Kaingaroa pine kingdoms.
The skate park in Kawerau. Between the early 1950s and late 1980s, the Tasman mill produced 20% of New Zealand’s exports.Photograph: Michael BradleyIn its heyday, Kawerau had a full-service supermarket, a department store, a video game parlour, and even competing cosmopolitan clubs.
Photograph: Michael BradleyI was born to a family with five living generations. My sisters and I knew our great-great-grandmother. This breeds a healthy respect for whakapapa – ancestry – and it nurtures a good knowledge of history, and how quickly things change. Nana Olga, my great-great-grandmother, was born before the Great War, into a political and economic world we can scarcely imagine. She was in work before turning thirteen while her brother was packed off to Europe to fight in the headtopics.com
Māoribattalion in the second world war. Nana Jean, my great-grandmother, was born between these upheavals – the first and second world wars – and the sacrifices from that time still shape her habits and preferences today. Nothing goes to waste at Nana Jean’s.
In regional New Zealand discrimination was more enthusiastic, as opposed to the lazy discrimination in Wellington.Morgan GodferyMy great-great-great-grandparents were told that these sacrifices – dispatching their young women to work and their young men to war – were, in Sir Āpirana Ngata’s words, “the highest demonstration of citizenship”. The losses of the second world war would ensure Pākehā respect. It was a neat recruitment tool, and true enough in parts. One of the first Labour government’s principal achievements was removing discrimination in the welfare state, ensuring post 1945 that Māori had access to benefits paid at the same rates as Pākehā. Yet hidden underneath this technical equality was discrimination in its application. Few Māori in the early 20th century had birth certificates, for example, meaning that only a small number were ever able to qualify for the old age pension.
In regional New Zealand discrimination was more enthusiastic, as opposed to the lazy discrimination in Wellington. In Gisborne, loan officers would turn down Māori for no other reason than they were Māori. In parts of the Waikato, Māori were barred from cinemas and refused service in high-end stores. In Tauranga, some public restrooms were off limits to Māori women and children. It took a decade after the war – and in some places longer – to tear down formal and informal discrimination.
In the 1990s, the Tasman mill’s workforce was cut in half, falling to fewer than 1,000 employees.Photograph: Michael BradleyAnd Kawerau was, in its own small way, part of this project to bring discrimination crashing down. The land the government acquired to build Tasman was sold on the promise, made by Sir James Fletcher, the great 20th-century industrialist, to the local hapū, that the mill would offers jobs to their children and grandchildren. headtopics.com
‘The proper direction of wealth is that it bubbles up’For the thirty years between 1954 and 1984 this promise held. The mills put thousands of hapū members to work. For some, it made modern living standards possible, from hot water to ovens and microwaves. But underneath this prosperity were rigid inequalities. Those same hapū members were more often than not the mill’s manual labour. When the thousands of Kawerau men punched in each morning Māori would form one line – to the sawmill, to the manual professions – while Pākehā would form another – to the better paid paper mills, to management, to engineering. My ancestors who made the decision to sell were possibly told that the wealth would trickle down. In 2021 we know better. The proper direction of wealth is that it bubbles up.
The worst violence is structural, because it’s necessarily inescapable. The mad genius of a boxing ring is it reproduces this. When an ordinary person is hit their first instinct is flight. But the boxing ring, its four corners roping opponents in, removes that choice. What separates the ordinary person from a boxer is that the latter’s purest impulse is to hit back. This is why boxing attracts the cast of characters that it does. Fitness freaks, naturally. But just as often men who are out of work, resentful. Gang members, traumatised. I remember one of Dad’s best boxers, a Commonwealth Games gold medallist, whose later life came crashing down as the accumulated stress of joblessness and homelessness chipped away at his sense of worth and personhood.
Gangs exist where the state failed, and it was left to communities like Kawerau to pick up the pieces.Morgan GodferyIn Kawerau it’s not unusual for people to go one of two ways. Of Dad’s boxers, most went on to good, secure work, prosperous families, and the peculiar dignity that comes from pummelling and getting pummelled. But others took the second way, falling into gang traps and poverty cycles. Before the 1960s New Zealand’s street gangs were more or less unheard of. But when the “borstal boys” came of age in the late 60s and early 70s – that is, the young men who were taken into state care in the 1950s – the Mongrel Mob, Black Power, the Filthy Few, and the bikie gangs became national boogeymen. Gangs exist where the state fails, and it was left to communities like Kawerau to pick up the pieces.
Read moreI grew up mostly with the sons and daughters of those people who took the second path, and we spent our childhoods in the ghost of Kawerau’s past. When we were growing up in the 1990s the Tasman mill’s workforce was cut in half, falling to fewer than 1,000 employees from a high of over 2,000. Roger Douglas’s callous decision to remove the government guarantee – import controls, industrial subsidies, and competition policy – meant the mills, with their well-paid workforce, were uncompetitive in international markets. Hundreds of hapū members were out of work. This was, in micro, what New Zealand was undergoing in macro. According to economist Brian Easton between 1989 and 1992 up to half of the New Zealand workforce went through a period of joblessness.
This was tough enough, breaking hundreds of families, but Ruth Richardson’s social reforms would break hundreds more still. In 1991 the National party finance minister made cruel cuts to the welfare state, removing the universal family benefit, slashing the unemployment and sickness benefits, and introducing a “user pays” system in hospitals and other public facilities. After the job cuts at Tasman, the Kawerau population went into decline and the men who were out of work – often Māori – found only the bones of a social support system. For those who were keen to retrain, they found an education system that they had to pay for out of their own pocket.
There are barely any Covid vaccination centres in rural Māori areas, making it hard for many to access them.Photograph: Michael Bradley‘Māori maintain good reasons for distrusting the Crown’In the space of a decade Kawerau went from perhaps the country’s most prosperous town to its poorest. Small business owners shut up shop and in their place government departments would open. Work and Income in the mall and the probation office in the business centre. The major development I remember in 1990s was the new police station. In 1996 more people were employed in community and social work – 17% of the workforce – than the wholesale and retail sectors – 16%. From the 1950s to the 1980s the government’s role was to guarantee Kawerau’s prosperity. But from the 1990s onward its role was to supervise the town’s dysfunction.
Māori, including Māori in Kawerau, maintain good reasons for distrusting the Crown and its successive governments. These are, after all, the same governments who broke their promises to the world war generations and the Māori battalions. These are the same governments who broke their promises to the local hapū, throwing thousands out of work for reasons of national policy. These are, of course, the same governments responsible for consistent Treaty of Waitangi breaches over the same decades too. With these histories in mind, Māori in Kawerau are probably rather sensible to interrogate the vaccine message.
This is hardly an excuse for wretched anti-vaxxers, whose idiocy endangers everyone. Every Māori who can get vaccinated should get vaccinated. Instead this is a challenge to the government. There are forces beyond ethnicity and access that are impeding the vaccine effort. History is. And to overcome that requires resourcing communities to deliver their own vaccination programs. In closed-off places like Kawerau or Murupara, only people the locals trust will be able to get the job done.Read more: The Guardian »
COVID live: WHO says new mutation 'a variant of concern' as EU imposes restrictions on seven African countries
Coronavirus latest as a new variant is identified in South Africa; Britain adds six countries to the red list from today; Grant Shapps says the government is taking a 'safety first' approach; Welsh rugby teams on tour in South Africa race to return.
Center for Disease Control and prevention ~ usagov
Covid news live: US to approve ‘mix and match’ booster shots, New Zealand reports record daily casesUS set to allow different Covid booster shots than the one initially taken; New Zealand experts sound warning over health system horrible Here are the known 'ADVERSE' VaccineSideEffects and the Number of people affected listed by the World Health Organization. If you or someone you care for are suffering from these Symptoms CONTACT YOUR DR (Search covid-19 vaccine )
Queensland announces Covid re-opening plan for borders scheduled ahead of Christmas – videoPremier Annastacia Palaszczuk flags re-opening to fully vaccinated visitors ahead of Christmas good luck It's happening in my FAMILY. A BIG organization's Representative/agent ARE USING MY GIRL/BOY's Body TO DO THEIR SOUL JOBS. May ALL OF YOU invading my boy/girl and my family GET your GOD/ANCESTRE 's attention of what vicious SOUL WORK you are doing to HARM THE KIDS! I generally wouldn’t do this but I think the cow in the qld premier’s office needs to go back to the future she came from
Italy has now become much easier to travel to from the UK, so here’s why this hotel in Rome needs to be top of your listItaly has now become much easier to travel to from the UK, so here’s why Rome's Villa Agrippina Gran Melia needs to be top of your list.
Jacinda Ardern blames rule-breakers as New Zealand sees record rise in Covid casesHealth officials have not been able to link over half of Tuesday’s cases to existing infections Does she not realise it's airborne yet? It will get in regardless & isolation weakens immunity by both introduction & psychological effects of hormone boosts by being around others.
New Zealand rugby star Sean Wainui dies aged 25 in horror car crash NEW ZEALAND rugby star Sean Wainui has tragically been confirmed dead after a horror car crash. The Maori All Blacks centre, 25, passed away after a single vehicle crash near Tauranga in New Z… So very sad🥲 Mercy Oh so horrible 🙏 RIP
Indian woman 'has her first child at 70'Jivunben Rabari welcomed a son through IVF this month. Jivunben, from Gujurat, India, was unable to prove her age, which she claims is 70, but could be one of the world's oldest new mothers. I just find this wrong . Poor wee baby is going to lose its mother at a young age. Wrong so wrong Or it could be April Fools day in India