Leaked test results suggest government and construction industry had evidence of dangers posed by cladding, 13 years before Grenfell Tower fire
The results of tests on panels commonly used in UK construction have been passed to the BBC.
The aluminium and plastic cladding at Grenfell has been blamed for spreading the fire.Two were constructed from high pressure laminate (HPL) boards, formed from wood, or paper fibre, widely used on modern apartment blocks in the UK.In the tests, all five cladding systems were judged to have failed against "proposed performance criteria".
Most of the tests were carried out without using "fire breaks" - extra components which should be fitted to block the spread of flames.However, fire breaks were used in one high pressure laminate panel system, but it still failed.'I might be bankrupt'
Zoe Bartley bought a three-room flat in Chelmsford four years ago, and with her partner Ash, now has a baby.They are desperate to move to a bigger home, but the cladding crisis means they cannot sell the flat.media captionZoe Bartley bought a flat in Chelmsford four years ago but can't sell it due to safety concerns headtopics.com
It has HPL panels, as well as wooden balconies and missing fire breaks,Zoe finds it "disgusting" that the test results were not circulated more widely.The couple are anticipating a bill of tens of thousands of pounds to remove the dangerous materials, which could bankrupt them.
"There's no finish line, and it's all-consuming at times," Zoe says."We are very angry that we've been put in this situation."We've done everything right. Everything by the book: 'Buy a property and set yourself up for the future.'
"I might end up bankrupt by the time I'm in my 30s."Her building is lower than 18 metres, so does not qualify for government funding.The UK Cladding Action Group called the test results "staggering new evidence which shows the government and its advisers knew these materials were dangerous, but simply stood back and allowed them to be installed on hundreds of thousands of buildings.
"The British state knew from this moment on that it was gambling with a disaster in a high-rise, but it chose not to act."'Route to disaster'Jonathan Evans, director of Ash and Lacy, a major UK supplier of cladding systems, said he had never seen the results, and described them as "really vital bits of information" which would have helped assess fire risks after Grenfell. headtopics.com
He said that when poor test data is not made public, it creates a bias towards tests with successful outcomes."We all proceed along the route of thinking these systems are safer than they are, until there's a disaster."image captionNot making poor test data public creates a bias towards tests with successful outcomes, argues Mr Evans
He said a lack of public information about cladding systems in the 2000s may have resulted in governments not abandoning a controversial British standard for building materials, known as Class 0.The Grenfell Tower inquiry has heard evidence that this standard was much easier to meet than a stricter European classification, and that keeping it as an option in England and Wales allowed combustible materials to be installed on thousands of buildings.
If Class 0 had been abandoned and a ban on combustible materials introduced, Grenfell might not have happened, Mr Evans said.Tests 'experimental'The Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government (MHCLG) described the 2004 tests as "experimental... for a different purpose" than the rounds of testing ordered in the wake of the Grenfell disaster.
They were carried out to "to check the criteria for testing" rather than to assess the "intrinsic safety of building materials", officials said.The findings fed into a review of technical standards used by building designers to assess the safety of cladding. headtopics.com
An MHCLG spokesman said: "We are taking action to improve building safety where successive governments have failed, through our Building Safety Bill, which marks the biggest improvements to building safety in 40 years, with more rights and protections for residents and a £5bn investment to remove unsafe cladding.
"The new Building Safety Regulator will enforce a more stringent regulatory regime for buildings over 18m and oversee the safety and performance of all buildings, ensuring products are removed from the market if they do not meet regulation."
The Building Research Establishment, which carried out the tests and circulated them to the industry advisory group, refused to comment.Next month the Grenfell Tower public inquiry will begin examining evidence of what governments knew about the risks of cladding fires before the 2017 disaster, and what they did about it.Read more: BBC News (UK) »
Inside Jisoo’s Touching First Trip To The Dior Ateliers
It’s a fairytale dream come true for the 26-year-old fashion plate.
What do you think all the delay is about? It’s so the elite and rich who have fingers in the construction/cladding cover up can cover their tracks. Same happened with Hillsborough/Thalidomide. In fact look at any major incident in UK that harmed many and it fits the same profile. DanKaszeta of course they knew
Well, yeah, that’ll happen when a government approves a cladding manufacturer as the safety tester of cladding to decide regulation on fire safety, won’t it? This is SO horrible! Put the blame where it belongs, the company that offered the option of an aluminium cladding with a combustible filling! Surely Corporate Manslaughter at least.
Love Island star Amy Hart says she had online death threat from 13-year-oldFormer contestant gives evidence to MPs about abuse and says social media firms are not doing enough to tackle trolling Damn. Sad. Lol boohoo
Apple’s iPhone 13 to hit shelves later this monthThe devices feature upgraded cameras and the company’s latest A15 chip, which it says is up to 50% faster than the competition My iPhone 4 is still working!
New iPhone 13 colours 'leaked' just one day before special Apple eventAPPLE looks set to unveil a new iPhone TODAY – but its colours may have been leaked. And we’re expecting a new pink colour option alongside the usual bunch. Apple is widely tipped to unveil t… Eh
When you can actually buy the iPhone 13Apple has announced the iPhone 13, Mini, Pro and Pro Max – as well as when people will actually be able to buy them. Who cares?
‘Do it for our kids’: Ardern urges people to get Covid vaccine as New Zealand reports 13 casesMobile vaccination buses head out to boost rollout as health officials trace movements of infected essential worker who travelled outside Auckland horrible See COVID in Ireland 🇮🇪 👇🏼 Good luck with that argument, New Zealand. Americans, on the other hand, demonstrably aren't moved by such treacle. America's children are but fodder in the COVID culture wars.