Boris is caught in another lie: Damning emails prove he DID help Carrie's friend Pen Farthing airlift dogs out of Kabul while people died - despite his adamant denials

  • PM said in December it was 'nonsense' that he intervened to help Pen Farthing
  • But emails today say it was 'the PM's decision' to assist his departure from Kabul
  • Volunteer at the charity  said last year he had lobbied Carrie Johnson personally

Advertisement

What Boris said about Paul Farthing

August 18, 2021 

He told the Commons: 'Like many of us, I have been lobbied extensively about the excellent work done by Mr Pen Farthing. I am well aware of his cause and all the wonderful things that he has done for animals in Afghanistan. I can tell my hon. Friend that we will do everything that we can to help Mr Farthing and others who face particular difficulties, as he does ... without in any way jeopardising our own national security.' 

December 7

When the row over No10 influencing the decision to help Mr Farthing first broke in December, the PM used a television interview to deride the claim, saying: 'That's complete nonsense. But what I can tell you is that I think that the Operation Pitting to airlift 15,000 people out of Kabul in the way that we did over the summer was one of the outstanding military achievements of the last 50 years or more.'

January 26, 2022

Emails released today by the Foreign Affairs Committee cited an official in the office of Lord Goldsmith, Foreign Office minister and close friend of Mrs Johnson, telling an official in his department 'the PM has just authorised their staff and animals to be evacuated'. A second email said: 'Having regard to the Prime Minister's Nowzad decision, the Foreign Secretary might consider the [details redacted] vets and their dependents should be included. They might be able to get to the airport with their dependents in time.'

Advertisement

Boris Johnson was accused by Labour of being a pathological liar today after emails revealed he intervened personally to help an animal charity boss associated with his wife flee the Taliban takeover of Afghanistan.

The Prime Minister has previously claimed on camera that it was 'nonsense' that he intervened to allow Paul 'Pen' Farthing and members of his Nowzad charity flee Kabul at the expense of locals as the extremists closed in last summer. 

But Foreign Office emails published by MPs today show officials discussing 'the PM's decision' to help Mr Farthing get onto some of the last planes out of the besieged city's airport. 

They also raise fresh question about the role played by the Prime Minister's wife in government affairs, after the charity admitted lobbying her directly to get action from the PM. 

In December volunteer Dominic Dyer told LBC radio 'I know Carrie Johnson' and said he had lobbied her personally to help the menagerie of 170 animals and their handlers get in the air.

The emails released today by the Foreign Affairs Committee cited an official in the office of Lord Goldsmith, Foreign Office minister and close friend of Mrs Johnson, telling an official in his department 'the PM has just authorised their staff and animals to be evacuated'.

That official later sent another message to other mandarins, saying: 'Having regard to the Prime Minister's Nowzad decision, the Foreign Secretary might consider the [details redacted] vets and their dependents should be included. They might be able to get to the airport with their dependents in time,' the emails said.

Labour branded Mr Johnson a 'pathological liar', with shadow defence secretary John Healey saying: 'Once again, the Prime Minister has been caught out lying about what he has been doing and deciding. 

'He should never have given priority to flying animals out of Afghanistan while Afghans who worked for our armed forces were left behind.'

Tonight Lord Goldsmith said: 'I did not authorise and do not support anything that would have put animals' lives ahead of peoples'. 

'My position, which I made clear publicly, was that the UK should prioritise evacuating people. I never discussed the Nowzad charity or their efforts to evacuate animals with the PM.'

Downing Street attempted to distance the PM from involvement in the decision on evacuating the Nowzad animals after the emails were released by the Foreign Affairs Committee.

The Prime Minister's official spokesman said: 'It remains the case that the PM didn't instruct officials to take any particular course of action.'

Downing Street has previously said neither of the Johnsons had any involvement, and insisted today: 'It remains the case that the PM didn't instruct officials to take any particular course of action.'

Defence Secretary Ben Wallace also said that 'at no point' was he 'directed' by Mr Johnson to prioritise evacuating the Nowzad contingent. 

And the whistleblower revelation will inflict more damage on Mr Johnson, who this lunchtime insisted he will not quit over Partygate and desperately suggested he is the victim of a Remainer conspiracy at a bruising PMQs.

The Prime Minister has previously denied intervening to allow Paul 'Pen' Farthing and members of his Nawzad charity flee Kabul at the expense of locals as the extremists closed in last summer.

The Prime Minister has previously denied intervening to allow Paul 'Pen' Farthing and members of his Nawzad charity flee Kabul at the expense of locals as the extremists closed in last summer.

The emails released today by the Foreign Affairs Committee cited an official in the office of Lord Goldmith (pictured), Foreign Office minister and close friend of Mrs Johnson, telling an official in his department 'the PM has just authorised their staff and animals to be evacuated'.

The emails released today by the Foreign Affairs Committee cited an official in the office of Lord Goldmith (pictured), Foreign Office minister and close friend of Mrs Johnson, telling an official in his department 'the PM has just authorised their staff and animals to be evacuated'. 

But Foreign Office emails published today show officials discussing 'the PM's decision' to help Mr Farthing get onto some of the last planes out of the besieged city's airport.

But Foreign Office emails published today show officials discussing 'the PM's decision' to help Mr Farthing get onto some of the last planes out of the besieged city's airport.

A volunteer at the charity run by former Royal Marine Paul Farthing said in December he had lobbied Carrie Johnson personally to help the menagerie of 170 animals get in the air.

A volunteer at the charity run by former Royal Marine Paul Farthing said in December he had lobbied Carrie Johnson personally to help the menagerie of 170 animals get in the air.

The damning emails 

August 25, 12:20pm

From: Official in Lord Goldsmith's private office

To: FCDO official

Subject: Animal Charity for Evacuation from Kabul 

'[animal charity – name redacted] are a [details redacted] animal charity operating in Kabul and seeking to evacuation (sic) their [details redacted] members of staff (no animals). 

'Equivalent charity Nowzad, run by an ex-Royal Marine, has received a lot of publicity and the PM has just authorised their staff and animals to be evacuated, [animal charity – name redacted] are hoping to be treated in the same capacity (granted LOTR).'

August 25, 5.42pm 

From: FCDO official 

To: Foreign Secretary's Private Office  

Subject: Evacuation - LOTR. URGENT for FS (Foreign Secretary) views

'In light of the PM's decision earlier today to evacuate the staff of the Nowzad animal charity, the [animal charity – name redacted] (another animal rights NGO) is asking for agreement to the entry of [details redacted] staff, all Afghan nationals...

'Having regard to the Prime Minister's Nowzad decision, the Foreign Secretary might consider the [details redacted] vets and their dependents should be included. They might be able to get to the airport with their dependents in time.'  

Advertisement

What happened in August 2021 as the Taliban took over Afghanistan?

Dozens of employees from Former Royal Marine Paul 'Pen' Farthings' animal shelter in Afghanistan were able to fly to Britain via Pakistan after the Taliban seized power in September 2020.

There were crazy scenes at the airport, one of the last allied footholds, as thousands of people attempted to flee the hardline Islamist regime., 

But the decision to get them out on one of the final flights out of Kabul sparked anger, after hundreds of locals who worked for allied forces were left behind. 

A volunteer at the charity later said he had lobbied Carrie Johnson personally to help the menagerie of 170 animals and their handlers get in the air.  

Dominic Dyer told LBC radio that the charity 'lobbied all the ministers' about the charter fight, as well as the PM's wife, a noted animal welfare campaigner.

'Obviously I know Carrie Johnson. I made very clear my concerns to her. No doubt she spoke to him (the PM)', he told the broadcaster.

'Carrie Johnson took the message forward, not just through me but through the Conservative Animal Welfare Foundation.' 

The plight of Farthing and his animals attracted much media attention in Britain, and led to a bitter row with defence minister Ben Wallace who said he could not allow anyone to jump the queue and would not prioritise pets over people.

What did Boris Johnson say about this claim that he did his wife's bidding?

The PM had previously directly denied intervening. When the row first broke in December he used a television interview to say: 'That's complete nonsense.

'But what I can tell you is that I think that the Operation Pitting to airlift 15,000 people out of Kabul in the way that we did over the summer was one of the outstanding military achievements of the last 50 years or more.'

Sir Laurie Bristow, who was on the ground as ambassador to Afghanistan during the withdrawal, told MPs today that no Afghans who could have been rescued were left behind as a result of the animal airlift.

Mr Johnson's spokesman said today he had not seen the emails, but repeated that the prime minister had not been involved.

'I know that the defence secretary yesterday made clear that at no stage .. did the prime minister ask him to make way for the pets, that no one jumped the queue and obviously we've made clear previously that the prime minister did not instruct officials to take any particular course of action,' he said. 

Yesterday the Defence Secretary insisted the Prime Minister did not ask him to clear the way out of Afghanistan for Mr Farthing's animals 'at any stage'. 

Appearing before the Foreign Affairs Committee, Ben Wallace said: 'No-one lobbied me... The Prime Minister didn't ring up. At no stage, at any stage, did the Prime Minister ask me to make a way for those pets. Not at all. Never.'

What does today's evidence show?

The emails released today by the Foreign Affairs Committee, chaired by Boris opponent Tom Tugendat, show officials directly linking the Prime Minister to the decision to get Mr Farthing and his team into the air.

The emails released today by the Foreign Affairs Committee, chaired by Boris opponent Tom Tugendat, show officials directly linking the Prime Minister to the decision to get Mr Farthing and his team into the air.

The emails released today by the Foreign Affairs Committee, chaired by Boris opponent Tom Tugendat, show officials directly linking the Prime Minister to the decision to get Mr Farthing and his team into the air. 

An official in the office of Lord Goldsmith - as a friend of Carrie Johnson - wrote: 'Equivalent charity Nowzad, run by an ex-Royal Marine, has received a lot of publicity and the PM has just authorised their staff and animals to be evacuated, [animal charity - name redacted] are hoping to be treated in the same capacity (granted LOTR).'

Another Foreign Office official wrote: about 'the PM's decision earlier today to evacuate the staff of the Nowzad animal charity', adding: 'Having regard to the Prime Minister's Nowzad decision, the Foreign Secretary might consider the [details redacted] vets and their dependents should be included. They might be able to get to the airport with their dependents in time.'

Additionally a senior official was heard saying Boris Johnson had issued the call for evacuation of Nowzad staff, whistleblower Raphael Marshall wrote in evidence to the Foreign Affairs Committee.

Carrie controversies that have dogged the PM

The row over Paul Farthing is the latest crisis for Boris Johnson involving his wife. 

Mr Farthing's charity said it lobbied the Prime Minister's wife in August to help get him and their animals out of Kabul before the Taliban took over Afghanistan.

But Mrs Johnson, who has two children with the PM, has also had a key role in other rows that have engulfed his premiership.

Although she is a former head of communications for the Conservative Party, she currently has no official role in the Government.

Sacking of Dom Cummings

Mrs Johnson was implicated in the decision to fire Dominic Cummings as the PM's chief advisor in late 2020.  He left No10 that December after losing a power struggle with her to get the PM's ear.

His allies were alleged to have referred to her as 'Princess Nut Nut', which enraged Mr Johnson and upset her. She is a skilled networker and environmental campaigner. And her views on animal welfare and the early release of violent criminals influenced Mr Johnson’s stance on the issues - frequently to Mr Cumming's frustration. There had long been annoyance over claims that Mrs Johnson was running a shadow PR operation, while she was said to have been incensed at the aggressive behaviour of Mr Cummings and his cadre. 

Downing Street flat redecoration

Carrie's dislike of the décor in the PM's official Downing Street flat is believed to have driven his desire to give the quarters a six-figure revamp.

A visitor to the flat is said to have described the interior left by Theresa May as a'John Lewis furniture nightmare' in Tatler.

The taxpayer funds a £30,000 annual allowance, but the redecoration - reportedly involving the company Soane, co-founded by designer Lulu Lytle - stretched beyond that.

Some reports suggest the upgrades hit the £200,000 mark, while a leaked email suggested Tory peer Lord Brownlow was making a £58,000 donation to the Conservatives 'to cover the payments the party has already made on behalf of the soon-to-be-formed 'Downing Street Trust'.

Partygate 

Carrie was dragged into the centre of Partygate this week over claims she organised a lockdown-busting birthday bash in June 2020. 

The PM's wife has already been placed at a number of contentious events in Downing Street during lockdown.

But on Monday ITV revealed she was behind a gathering in the Cabinet Room in No10 on June 19, 2020, to celebrate him turning 56.

They are said to have celebrated his birthday after his return from a visit to a school in Hertfordshire, where he had posed with his arms outstretched with children to show the importance of social distancing. 

The event saw staff join in with a chorus of happy birthday as the PM was presented with a Union Jack cake.  

Those present included Ms Lytle, though she said she happened to pass by on her way to speak to the PM.

Advertisement

Mr Marshall wrote: 'On Wednesday 25 August, I heard the senior official ('Crisis Silver') responsible for Afghan Special Cases say that they had just received an instruction from the Prime Minister to ''call-forward'' Nowzad's staff to Kabul Airport for evacuation.

'I then heard Silver instruct team members to send the names and passport details of Nowzad's staff to the Home Office for security-checks.

'A colleague said ''we are doing the dogs'' or ''we are doing the dog people''. A colleague said that the Prime Minister had issued this instruction in a COBR meeting. It is possible the high-level meeting referred to was in-fact technically a National Security Council meeting.' 

Mr Marshall also said that multiple colleagues wrote on the Teams message system that the Prime Minister had given an instruction over Nowzad staff.

Mr Marshall's written evidence said: 'Several colleagues sent messages on the Afghan Special Cases group on Microsoft Teams to the effect that the Prime Minister had instructed us to call-forward Nowzad's staff for evacuation.'

Has any other evidence shed doubt on the Prime Minister's denial? 

In December, Labour MP Chris Bryant reveled a letter sent by Mr Johnson's political private secretary Trudy Harrison to Mr Farthing, in which she said British authorities would help 68 staff and the animals flee. 

In the letter dated August 25, Ms Harrison said she had 'received confirmation' from the Foreign Office, Home Office and Ministry of Defence they would be permitted to travel to the airport.

She said Defence Secretary Ben Wallace had 'made it clear' that all 68 of the shelter's staff and their family members would be able to board an RAF flight.

'The Secretary of State has also confirmed that animals under the care of Nowzad [Mr Farthing's shelter] can be evacuated on a separate, chartered flight,' she continued.

'The Ministry of Defence will ensure that a flight slot is available... You are therefore authorised to proceed, I wish you well on your journey.'  

Whistleblower Mr Marshall said it was 'not credible' for No 10 to claim was acting in her capacity as a constituency MP, as has been claimed.

Addressing the letter he wrote: 'It is not credible to suggest that the 'call-forward' of Nowzad's staff was initiated by the Prime Minister's then Parliamentary Private Secretary Trudy Harrison MP in her capacity as MP for Copeland.

'A request for the evacuation of Nowzad's staff from Ms Harrison in her capacity as MP for Copeland would have been disregarded.'

What are MPs saying about today's revelations?

Labour former minister Chris Bryant raised questions in the Commons about how he could 'get to the bottom of who is telling the truth' over evacuation of a charity and its animals from Afghanistan.

Raising a point of order, he said: 'The Prime Minister said on August 26 that he had no influence on that particular case and nor would that be right.

'On December 7 he was asked ''Did you intervene to get Pen Farthing's animals out?'', he said ''No, that is complete nonsense''. And a Downing Street spokesperson said ''Neither the Prime Minister nor Mrs Johnson were involved''.

'Yet today the Foreign Affairs Committee has been able to publish a letter from Lord Goldsmith's office which says the ''Prime Minister has just authorised their staff and animals to be evacuated''.

'How can I get to the bottom of who is telling the truth?'

Liberal Democrat foreign affairs spokeswoman Layla Moran also raised concerns about the matter, including on the 'discrepancy between what the Prime Minister says to journalists versus what is revealed' in the Commons. 

What does Paul Farthing say?

Animal welfare charity Nowzad said founder Paul Farthing was only able to leave Kabul 'after the British military had already ended Operation Pitting'.

In a statement, the charity said: 'Once more the Nowzad charity is appalled to find ourselves at the centre of a political media debate on who did what and when in relation to Operation Ark.

'Sixty-seven vulnerable Afghans were evacuated against all odds from Afghanistan by road to start new lives in the United Kingdom. This should be an achievement that is celebrated not used for political point scoring.

'As a charity, we had no oversight of any communication between any Government departments relating to who authorised the call forward of the Nowzad staff.

'We found out at the same time as everyone else, when (Defence Secretary) Ben Wallace tweeted our approval at 1.30am on August 25.

'Sadly, it was too late to ensure the evacuation flight that our supporters had fundraised for, would be able to transport our staff to safety.

'Only Pen Farthing (a British passport holder), with the Nowzad rescued animals in the cargo hold, was able to leave Kabul airport after the British military had already ended Operation Pitting. No British military were put in harm's way or supported Pen Farthing during his two attempts to gain access to Kabul airport.'

The comments below have not been moderated.

The views expressed in the contents above are those of our users and do not necessarily reflect the views of MailOnline.

We are no longer accepting comments on this article.