Registration of bicycles, licensing of cyclists may not make roads safer, say observers
SINGAPORE: Requiring cyclists to be licensed or bicycles to be registered may not have the desired effect of keeping roads in Singapore safe, say ...
REVIVING REGISTRATIONBicycles were required to be registered here from the colonial era until 1982, when the practice was discontinued.But over the years, there have been numerous calls to revive the licensing of the two-wheelers and their riders.In 2013, former Nee Soon GRC Member of Parliament Lee Bee Wah had suggested that cyclists be required to take safety lessons before being issued licences.
AdvertisementThe suggestion resurfaced in 2016, when numerous letters to the Straits Times forum called for registration as a means of deterring errant riders.The Land Transport Authority (LTA) had responded to the letters saying it had studied licensing “very carefully”, but cited “practical difficulties” in implementing such a scheme.
Implementing and managing a licensing system would be too resource-intensive, said LTA then, adding that there are concerns riders would be discouraged from cycling as it would be too onerous to own a bicycle.Similar reasons have been cited for the rejection of bike licensing requirements in other cities, such as Los Angeles and Seattle in the United States. headtopics.com
Still, there are other locales which have such schemes in place, such as Japan, where it exists largely as an anti-theft measure.In Honolulu, cyclists have to pay a one-time US$15 (S$20) registration fee for all bicycles with wheels that are at least 20 inches in diameter. This move brings in a reported US$400,000 (S$534,950) each year for the Hawaiian capital.
A lone cyclist rides through circular road in Singapore where most shops are closed amid circuit breaker measures to contain COVID-19. (Photo: Marcus Mark Ramos)REGISTRATION PROS AND CONSThere are a number of possible benefits associated with the registration of bicycles, said Dr Cecilia Rojas, whose research is focused on active mobility.
In addition to greater enforcement of safety regulations, registration could help reduce instances of bike theft as well as abandoned or illegally parked two-wheelers, noted the Singapore University of Social Sciences (SUSS) lecturer.Any such scheme should have clear regulations regarding who needs to be registered, and be adopted gradually so as to give people enough time to adapt, she said, adding that the licensing process should be “straightforward and easy”.
But Dr Rojas added that it would be challenging to introduce a licensing framework that could cater to different types of cyclists, noting also there could be difficulties in implementing registration for different types of bicycles.READ: Singapore sees cycling boom amid COVID-19, with increased ridership and bicycle sales headtopics.com
“Bicycles are bought, sold, exchanged very regularly. Also, in cases of road bicycles, sometimes just the frame or the handle or the wheels are changed, making the bicycle lighter or faster. Would these types of changes be required to be informed (to the authorities), or a new licence be required?” she asked.
The inconvenience of the process could deter people from cycling, she added, echoing Mr Chee’s concerns.Although registration is required for e-bikes and e-scooters, transport expert Tham Chen Munn questioned how effective this has been in enhancing road safety.
Mr Tham, who is a business development director for traffic solutions firm PTV Asia-Pacific, questioned if the registration for these devices - which requires that they display an identification number - had assisted in catching errant riders.Cycling advocate Francis Chu noted that e-scooters were eventually banned from footpaths despite requiring registration.
“On the roads, vehicles move faster and the distance between them is further apart compared to those on the pavement. If on the footpath it didn't help address the errant riders, it will be more difficult to capture the number plate on the road,” said the co-founder of cycling group Love Cycling SG. headtopics.com
Mr Chu suggested there could be a risk of drivers tailing errant cyclists so as to identify their number plates.Speaking to the media on Monday, Safe Cycling Task Force president Steven Lim - a member of the Active Mobility Advisory Panel - had said the issue of errant cyclists is a “behavioural” problem, noting that there are also errant motorists despite the stringent requirements to obtain a driving license.
READ: Electric bicycle riders must pass theory test to ride on roads under proposed changes to Road Traffic ActMAKING ROAD CYCLING SAFERMr Chu, who also previously sat on the Active Mobility Advisory Panel, suggested cyclists could be required to take an online test on how to cycle safely on the road, while drivers could also be encouraged to take a similar test on how to react to cyclists on the road.
He said the LTA should consult experienced cyclists on “problematic areas”, adding that infrastructure such as protected bike lanes and junctions could be introduced in certain areas if space allows.Speed limits in certain areas could also be reduced in certain areas to keep cyclists and pedestrians safe, said Mr Tham.
He pointed to the United Nations’ support for a 30kmh speed limit in “areas where vulnerable road users and vehicles mix in a frequent and planned manner” as part of its second Decade of Action for Road Safety, which begins this year.This can be done in areas with a “high density of people walking and cycling”, he added.
“We're not talking about expressways, we're not talking about major arterials, leave those as they are. There are opportunities to (introduce a speed limit of) 30kmh in places that can be safe for people to come out and play and be more active,” he said.
READ: Commentary: Banning bicycles from footpaths won’t make poor cycling habits disappearDr Rojas of SUSS suggested that greater educational efforts, rather than a mandatory theory test, would best keep cyclists safe.“My four-year-old - and many others - rides a bicycle and although he doesn't know how to read or write, and hence can’t take a theory test, he is aware that he should dismount and push at certain areas, (stay) on which side of the footpath to ride, where to wait for the green man and other bicycle regulations,” she said.
“This behaviour is obtained through education and encouragement.”The burden of such educational efforts should not fall purely on cyclists, but also on all road users to “acknowledge, respect, and co-exist” safely, she said.“Considering that the cycling rate, although increasing, is still relatively low in Singapore, campaigns of encouragement, information and education might be the best approach to improve safety and increase the active mobility rate.”Read more: CNA »
2 influencers face deportation from Bali over painted-on face mask prank
This seems to be noises made by those cyclist in groups and closing off lanes while not adhering to road traffic rules and not held responsible or need to follow the law on public roads or pavements. True very true License for the privilege to excercise? George Orwell would be so proud 🙄 pedestrians should also take licence on the how to walk and differentiate on paths
OCBC says it 'may not need so many branches' with plans to review office spaceSINGAPORE: Singapore’s second largest bank OCBC will be reviewing its office space requirements, including the number of bank branches it has, ... And with the success the of wfh for some of the positions, why bring the foreigner here to work when you can hire them directly from their own country without having them come here, pay the tax, contribute to the work pass levy, cost lesser and hired as a contractor.
34 errant cyclists caught over two days, including 2 riding against traffic flow: LTASINGAPORE: Thirty-four cyclists were caught breaking the rules on roads over the weekend, said the Land Transport Authority (LTA) on Sunday (Apr 18). Trade_Haven Cyclists have to be educated that riding against traffic flow is dangerous. They are endangering themselves! They should abide by traffic rules. It's for the sake of their own safety! By the time an accident happens, it may be too late. This is why cyclist should be banned from the roads! Causing inconveniences to drivers Hahaha
34 errant cyclists caught over weekend, including 2 riding against traffic flow: LTASINGAPORE — Thirty-four cyclists were caught breaking the rules on roads over the weekend, the Land Transport Authority (LTA) said on Sunday (April 18). YESSSSS!!!!!
Decision on domestic spectators for Tokyo Olympics may come in June - MainichiA decision on limits for domestic spectators for the Tokyo Olympics may not be made until June, the month before the scheduled start of the games, ...
Covid-19: No singing at religious services from May 8, testing required for services involving over 100 peopleSINGAPORE — From Saturday (May 8), worshippers at religious services will not be allowed to sing, as the authorities scaled back on an allowance that was made just a month ago.