Hong Kong shifts aim from the virus to property: Andy Mukherjee

Yahoofinance, Hong Kong, Stimulus Package, Coronavirus

COVID-19: Hong Kong Budget packs less punch than Singapore's #YahooFinance

Yahoofinance, Hong Kong

2/27/2020

COVID-19: Hong Kong Budget packs less punch than Singapore's YahooFinance

If the quantum of public spending alone decided the seriousness in fighting the coronavirus, then Hong Kong ’s HK$120 billion package ought to be 3 times punchier than rival Singapore.

By Andy Mukherjee (Bloomberg Opinion) -- If the quantum of public spending alone decided the seriousness with which small, open Asian economies are fighting the coronavirus, then Hong Kong’s HK$120 billion ($15.4 billion) package ought to be three times punchier than rival Singapore’s. When it comes to the quality of expenditure and the financing, though, Hong Kong’s plan seems to be less about protecting lives and livelihoods, and more about preserving the island’s frothy property market. The centerpiece of Financial Secretary Paul Chan’s antidote is a HK$10,000 cash handout to all adult permanent residents. Additionally, Hong Kong will offer bigger income and profit tax rebates, and provide subsidies on utility bills as well as government guaranteed low-interest loans to small- and medium-size businesses. From cancelled orders and stuck payments to inventory pileups, SMEs may be worst-affected by the outbreak. Supporting them is necessary. But how reasonable is a handout for all? The S$6.4 billion ($4.6 billion) anti-viral budget recently announced by Singapore also has a cash component. But for high-income earners and property owners without young children, it comes to just S$100 — less than HK$600. Although the needy and elderly will get more, the bulk of Singapore’s extra spending will support firms and shore up health expenditure. Hong Kong, however, seems to be using the virus as an excuse to splash money: Almost 60% of its stimulus package is doing just that. All told, the budget deficit for the fiscal year 2020-21 will balloon to HK$139 billion, or 4.8% of gross domestic product, up from about HK$38 billion for the current fiscal year. The headline figures could be deceptive, though, considering that even this year’s deficit was largely a meaningless number. It included money set aside for a HK$30 billion anti-epidemic fund, which will only be used next fiscal year to give a one-time special allowance to low-income households and subsidies for students. Strip that out, and Hong Kong’s first budget shortfall in 15 years was basically an optical illusion. Next year may be the same story. The four rounds of relief measures the city has announced since August to offset some of the economic impact of anti-government protests have already put some cash in people’s pockets. Soon the additional HK$10,000 checks will hit their bank accounts. If the virus gets contained in a few months, those with secure jobs may be encouraged to use the windfall to put a step on the city’s impossibly expensive property ladder. And even if the monetary incentive is too small for them to do that, their landlords will know that they can ask for higher rents since every family of two permanent resident adults and their two school-going children will be getting a total of HK$27,000 in cash from the government and paying slightly lower taxes. Stable rental yield on existing properties will support new real-estate launches. What the government earns from stamp duties — some of which are meant to keep housing prices in check — will rise. So will revenue from land sales to developers, especially when the city with some of the world’s least-affordable real estate starts hawking parcels under the controversial Lantau Tomorrow program. The 4.8% deficit could end up much lower, but long-term public finances would be that much more reliant on property prices. It’s a dangerous addiction. In the first five years of the millennium, revenue from land premium and stamp duty together accounted for 13% of government revenue. Now they bring in a third. Profit tax still remains the single-biggest individual contributor, but even here there’s little broadening of the base. Property, investment, banking and finance, wholesale trade and import and export account for two-thirds of profit tax collections; nine out of 10 companies in Hong Kong pay nothing at all. Every second employed worker shells out some income taxes, though with the 100% relief that Chan has announced (with the reduction capped at HK$20,000), even the base of the salary tax pyramid will become narrower. Hong Kong doesn’t have Singapore’s consumption tax, or casino earnings. Singapore’s sovereign wealth fund and state investment arm are now the No. 1 contributor to its budget, whereas investment income has become a negligible part of Hong Kong’s public revenue over the years. Given its long-term funding constraints, Hong Kong needs to be more prudent than to splurge indiscriminately. The cash it’s throwing around isn’t a protection against coronavirus. It will only stimulate what doesn’t need any more encouragement: the property market. © 2020 Bloomberg L.P. Read more: Yahoo Singapore

Hong Kong extends school suspension until April 20 to control spread of virus Hong Kong has further extended the suspension of schools until at least April 20 to contain the spread of the coronavirus, authorities in the Asian financial hub said on Tuesday as cases of the disease surged outside China. The city's Secretary for Education Kevin Yeung said classes would be suspended

Hong Kong Buddhist temple becomes host to cluster of coronavirus infections HONG KONG (CAIXIN GLOBAL) - Hong Kong 's health authority reported two new confirmed cases of Covid-19 on Tuesday (Feb 25) that are related to a cluster of six people who had been infected after visiting the same Buddhist temple in the city at the end of January or early February.. Read more at straitstimes.com.

Hong Kong: Stocks open lower but Shanghai risesHongKong: Stocks open lower but Shanghai rises

Hong Kong stock exchange enjoys upbeat 2019 despite protests Hong Kong stock exchange enjoys upbeat 2019 despite protests HKEX HKEXGroup HongKongProtests covid19 virus

Hong Kong to announce largest budget in a decade amid protests, coronavirus HONG KONG (REUTERS) - Hong Kong is expected to announce its largest budget deficit in at least a decade on Wednesday (Feb 26) to cushion the shock of often-violent protests and the outbreak of a coronavirus on the recession-hit economy.. Read more at straitstimes.com.

Hong Kong to announce largest budget in a decade amid protests, coronavirus Hong Kong is expected to announce its largest budget deficit in at least a decade on Wednesday to cushion the shock of often-violent protests and ...



49 new COVID-19 cases in Singapore; Mustafa Centre among 3 new clusters identified

NTUC FairPrice closes Finest store at Bedok Mall for cleaning after employee contracts COVID-19

Number of COVID-19 cases in Singapore reach 1,000; old age home among 2 new clusters identified

Coronavirus: Malaysian economy will recover but will take time, says former PM Mahathir

Number of COVID-19 cases in Singapore reaches 1,000; old age home among 2 new clusters identified

Palm View Primary School student tests positive for COVID-19, home-based learning extended

Singapore confirms 4th death from COVID-19

Write Comment

Thank you for your comment.
Please try again later.

Latest News

News

27 February 2020, Thursday News

Previous news

Air New Zealand tests beds for economy passengers

Next news

SMRT joins CapitaLand in cutting wages for managerial staff in light of Covid-19 outbreak
Man arrested after lingerie goes missing from Tampines home, thousands of undergarments seized SingPost COVID-19 cluster caused by employee who went to work despite being unwell: Iswaran Potential Covid-19 vaccine shows promise in trials on mice Half of humanity in coronavirus confinement Mecca, Medina get 24-hour curfew; Gulf migrant worker districts locked down My First Skool in Rivervale Crescent to close temporarily after teacher diagnosed with Covid-19 North Korea insists it is free of coronavirus North Korea insists it is free of coronavirus Global air passenger demand sees steepest decline since 9/11: IATA Coronavirus: Staff at a New York hospital put protective gear in outdoor trash can after handling bodies As millions lose jobs, Fed policymakers say recession is here Coronavirus: British Airways temporarily lays off 28,000 staff
49 new COVID-19 cases in Singapore; Mustafa Centre among 3 new clusters identified NTUC FairPrice closes Finest store at Bedok Mall for cleaning after employee contracts COVID-19 Number of COVID-19 cases in Singapore reach 1,000; old age home among 2 new clusters identified Coronavirus: Malaysian economy will recover but will take time, says former PM Mahathir Number of COVID-19 cases in Singapore reaches 1,000; old age home among 2 new clusters identified Palm View Primary School student tests positive for COVID-19, home-based learning extended Singapore confirms 4th death from COVID-19 China's Shenzhen bans the eating of cats and dogs after coronavirus Coronavirus: New study finds at least 10 patients in Singapore caught virus from those without symptoms 'Shoot them dead': Duterte says he won't tolerate violators of lockdown against coronavirus NTUC FairPrice closes Bedok Mall supermarket for 3 days for cleaning after employee diagnosed with Covid-19 49 new coronavirus cases in S'pore; 3 new clusters at Mustafa Centre, Maxwell station worksite and Keppel Shipyard