Commentary: The broader dialogue the US-China relationship needs
Broader dialogue with greater room for cooperation, underpinned by strong, personal relationships can help both sides strike a better balance in ...
But what is really needed may be a much broader dialogue.At the last meeting of the US-China Strategic and Economic Dialogue, held in Beijing in 2016, the large US delegation, led jointly by the secretaries of state and the Treasury, included officials responsible for issues such as climate policy, ocean health, counterterrorism, non-proliferation, food security, and mineral supply-chain practices. Agreements were reached in every area.
AdvertisementIf this kind of broad US-China dialogue were to be held today, imagine what the US side of the table would look like.Alongside Blinken and Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen, we could expect to see Secretary of Commerce Gina Raimondo, Trade Representative Katherine Tai, Chair of the Council of Economic Advisers Cecilia Rouse, White House National Climate Adviser Gina McCarthy (the first woman to hold that position), and Samantha Power, the incoming administrator of the US Agency for International Development.
Secretary of State Antony Blinken, left, listens as National Security Adviser Jake Sullivan, right, talks to the media after a closed-door morning session of US-China talks in Anchorage, Alaska on Friday, March 19, 2021. (Photo: AP/Frederic J. Brown)Environmental Protection Agency Administrator Michael Regan, Secretary of Health and Human Services Xavier Becerra, and Attorney General Merrick Garland would join them. headtopics.com
That would be a far better picture to present to the world – a diverse array of US officials, over half of them women, confronting a phalanx of Chinese men – than the images from the Alaska summit, which could have been taken anywhere between 1972 and the present.
Get the expert viewThe best commentaries and analysis to better help you see beyond today’s news headlines. Subscribe to CNA’s Commentary newsletter.Invalid email addressIt looks like the email address you entered is not valid.Try AgainThis service is not intended for persons residing in the EU. By clicking subscribe, I agree to receive news updates and promotional material from Mediacorp and Mediacorp's partners.
Sign me upREAD: Commentary: After Alaska, age of selective engagement in US-China relations beginsMAKING WOMEN THE FACE OF DIALOGUESIn a similar vein, the United States could propose a bilateral dialogue exclusively on cybersecurity and data-privacy issues, alongside planned dialogues on issues like climate change. Here, again, women would dominate the American side of the table.
They include Anne Neuberger (Deputy National Security Adviser for Cyber and Emerging Technology), Jen Easterly (awaiting Senate confirmation as the National Cyber Director), and Mieke Eoyang (Deputy Assistant Secretary of Defense for Cyber Policy). Shannon Coe, Jennifer Daskal, Melanie Hart, and Cynthia Carras would also be in attendance. headtopics.com
Making these women the public face of the American half of a US-China cyber-policy dialogue would be good for women everywhere.Moreover, much like a single broad dialogue, the simultaneous pursuit of multiple targeted dialogues would highlight the complexity of the bilateral relationship and the importance of cooperation on a wide range of issues.
To be sure, simply replacing male officials with women will not bring about harmony in Sino-American relations.Just ask Canadian Deputy Prime Minister Chrystia Freeland, who has been locked in unproductive negotiations to free Michael Spavor and Michael Kovrig since they were arrested in China and charged with espionage, apparently in retaliation for Canada’s 2018 arrest of Meng Wanzhou, Huawei’s CFO, at the request of the US.
READ: Commentary: The US’ greatest asset in East Asia may be JapanBut as Biden well knows, foreign policy – like politics more broadly – is based on relationships created not only at the negotiating table, but also after hours, unwinding over an informal meal and finding common interests and identities.
These relationships are necessary to build actual trust and convince senior government officials to drop their figurative masks and reveal the real person.BUILDING STRONGER PERSONAL RELATIONSHIPSWhen Hillary Clinton was Secretary of State, she forged a relationship with Chinese State Councilor Dai Bingguo, based partly on their shared commitment to their children and grandchildren. That relationship helped the US and China to weather a major diplomatic crisis. headtopics.com
Chinese Foreign Minister Wang Yi, seen on a November 2020 visit to Seoul. (Photo: AFP/Kim Min-Hee)Today, building such relationships – essential to foster trust between high officials – should be a top priority of US leaders, regardless of gender. Such an effort could build on the ties being created through unofficial dialogues.
For example, as the Alaska summit was unfolding, women from the US, China, and Europe gathered via Zoom for a private discussion about Internet censorship.This group – including multiple generations of government officials, academics, business leaders, investors, and journalists – meets regularly for candid, off-the-record conversations about some of today’s most pressing topics, from artificial-intelligence start-ups to export controls and biotechnology. These relationships could prove very useful to governments.
As Kerry has noted, the US will never accept China’s violations of human rights and trade abuses in exchange for climate cooperation.READ: Commentary: China's boycott of H&M, Nike and other big brands is really bizarreBut cooperation on climate change – as well as pandemics, cybersecurity, and other shared threats – remains critical.
Only with a broad (or multi-pronged) dialogue, led by a different set of faces and fortified by deeper personal relationships, can the US strike the right balance between – to use Blinken’s words – the adversarial and cooperative aspects of its relationship with China.
Anne-Marie Slaughter, a former director of policy planning in the US State Department, is CEO of the think tank New America, Professor Emerita of Politics and International Affairs at Princeton University, and the author of Unfinished Business: Women Men Work Family. Samm Sacks is Cyber Policy Fellow at New America and Senior Fellow at Yale Law School’s Paul Tsai China Center. She also convenes the US-China Women's Tech Summit.Read more: CNA »
Singapore sees ‘several important lessons’ from Tan Tock Seng Hospital COVID-19 cluster
SINGAPORE: Singapore has learnt 'several important lessons' from the COVID-19 cluster at Tan Tock Seng Hospital (TTSH), among them - that the ...
China, Russia and ASEAN It is pushing Burma's civil war. Most ASEAN countries are slaves to China. We, the people of Burma, do not accept evil China and Russia
Commentary: China more focused on getting rich than it is in stoking US rivalryChinese policymakers are less afraid of economic decoupling from the US than many assume, say Andrew Sheng and Xiao Geng.
Commentary: Cooperation between US, China at global climate summit could yield significant benefitsSecuring mutual commitment of both superpowers will be needed to meet targets set in the Paris Agreement, says Yale-NUS College’s Yew Wei Lit. No, the PRC is a rogue state, it is what the US would have been if the Trump coup had succeeded: a one party criminal totalitarian regime
Biden says US must invest because China 'eating our lunch'President Joe Biden warned Thursday that Congress needs to adopt his multi-trillion dollar spending plans to renew the US economy because China is 'eating our lunch.'
Japan expresses concerns to China about territorial waters, Hong Kong, Uighur situationJapanese Foreign Minister Toshimitsu Motegi on Tuesday expressed strong concerns to his Chinese counterpart about Chinese incursions into territorial waters, the situation in Hong Kong and the human rights situation of China's Uighur minority. China's extensive territorial claims in the East and South China Seas have become a priority issue in an increasingly testy Sino-U.S relationship and are a security concern for Japan.
Commentary: Higher learning institutes need to change strategies to groom IT talentThe demand for deep tech is only going to grow and the only way for Singapore to produce local talent is to change the way we teach digital ...