Some political observers said the idea of a government free of political lines and in which any lawmaker from any party could be appointed as minister was too idealistic.
KOTA KINABALU, Feb 27 — Tun Dr Mahathir Mohamad’s ambitious call for a non-partisan government was commendable for its progressive vision, according to political observers who went on to doubt...
Some said the idea of a government free of political lines and in which any lawmaker from any party could be appointed as minister was too idealistic.Others also said Malaysia was in no position for such a political experiment when it was already contending with slowing economic growth and a still-unresolved coronavirus disease (Covid-19) episode.
Universiti Teknologi Mara Sabah’s Tony Paridi Bagang was cautiously optimistic about the concept as a way out of the political uncertainty.“With the current economic downturn and the Covid-19 outbreak, it's high time everyone of them to work together.
“It’s never been done here but anyone can see it will be hard to sustain because of the current interest groups,” he said.However, Bagang said that in the past, similar “co-sharing” concepts had not worked — at least not in the long term — due to opposing ideologies and personal agendas.
“We’ve had Pakatan Harapan try before GE14 but even they could not sustain it with Tun Mahathir there. What more when Tun is no longer leading? It is doable, sure, but not sustainable,” he said.“Unless of course, the parties or the coalitions are able to get their consensus and mutually agree on the terms,” he said.
Dr Mahathir, in his first public address since the political turmoil began last Sunday, asked to be given the opportunity to form and lead a non-partisan government covering the entire political spectrum.He resigned unexpectedly as the prime minister on Monday following open speculation of a power grab involving his Bersatu, a rogue PKR faction headed by Datuk Seri Azmin Ali, and several Opposition parties.
After this fell through, Dr Mahathir still appeared to be on track to return as PM after nearly all major political parties expressed support for him to remain.Barisan Nasional, PAS, and PBRS have since withdrawn support for Dr Mahathir and rejected the unity government proposal after saying they would not work with DAP.
University Malaysia Sabah associate professor Lee Kuok Tiung also supported the notion of a non-partisan administration in principle but doubted that it would be possible given the deep enmities among Malaysian parties and politicians.“First, DAP and PKR will have to mend fences with Bersatu. GPS is also unlikely to want to work with PKR and DAP, due to intense rivalries in Sarawak.
“GPS still needs to pander to the state’s interest as their state elections are coming up,” he said, referring to Gabungan Parti Sarawak (formerly Sarawak BN) that is the state government in Sarawak.He also said such a government would need to find ways for Azmin’s faction to co-exist with PH and PKR that accused the group of betrayal and engineering the collapse of the government.
Lee said it was unlikely that PKR could forgive Azmin and his supporters, and noted that Dr Mahathir has yet to say how he would accommodate PKR president Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim who had been his anointed successor until the PH administration fell.“There are a lot of considerations that are not straightforward that can bamboozle the Cabinet if not solved amicably,” said Lee.
“If Pakatan Harapan can persuade PPBM to reconcile, it may work. But you still need them to be on good terms with Umno and maybe PAS,” he said.However, one political analyst linked to a national think tank said that the non-partisan concept could be successful if Dr Mahathir handpicked individuals with principles and integrity who could look past party affiliations.
“If individuals are matured, and can do the work without playing politics, it is a workable system. The role of running the government should be carried out responsibly and if they can look past their political differences, they can cobble together a good Cabinet,” said the analyst who declined to be named.
He said he agreed with Dr Mahathir that it was a viable solution in the current climate, which needed stability and focus in the face of real world challenges.He said that such non partisan government systems are currently working successfully, albeit in countries with smaller populations as well as some states.
“But whether you can pick the right people, is another story altogether. But I think we do have capable leaders in all the parties. But leading and working together is the question.” he said.
Read more: Yahoo Singapore
It is indeed progressive and idealistic...so was democracy thousands of years ago and communism round about hundred year ago.
Malaysia's Mahathir proposes 'unity government' to strengthen gripKUALA LUMPUR — Malaysia's Mahathir Mohammed is trying to form a national unity government under his personal authority, drawing together rival parties, political sources said on Tuesday (Feb 25), following his shock resignation as prime minister.
Mahathir proposes to lead 'unity government' in Malaysia, say sourcesKUALA LUMPUR (REUTERS) - Malaysia's Mahathir Mohamad is proposing to lead a unity government and has invited lawmakers from across rival political parties to join, political sources said on Tuesday (Feb 25), after his shock resignation as premier.. Read more at straitstimes.com.
Unity government under Dr M? Umno sec-gen says will be hypocritical after Pakatan collapseKUALA LUMPUR — Umno has rejected the idea of a unity government under the leadership of Dr Mahathir Mohamad, its secretary-general Annuar Musa asserted on Tuesday (Feb 25).
Some Malaysia state governments face limbo amid political turmoilJOHOR BAHRU: The fate of some Malaysian state governments are in question after recent political developments in the country that saw Prime ...
At Dataran Merdeka, young Malaysians denounce ‘backdoor government’ attemptKUALA LUMPUR, Feb 25 — A group of student activists and representatives from several non-government organisations gathered at the historic Dataran Merdeka this evening demanding the country’s...
Football: Zidane casts doubt on Hazard return this seasonZinedine Zidane said on Tuesday he cannot be sure that Eden Hazard will play again this season after the Belgian suffered another foot injury last ...