P N Balji, my former SPH colleague, has given the Multi-Ministry Task Force on Covid-19 a six out of 10 rating for its handling of the pandemic so far. He said in his Facebook blog, The New Singapore,headlined, “Singapore’s patchy Covid-19 report
P N Balji, my former SPH colleague, has given the Multi-Ministry Task Force on Covid-19 a six out of 10 rating for its handling of the pandemic so far. He said
The New Singapore, headlined,“Singapore’s patchy Covid-19 report card”: “I gave the leadership a seven out of 10 rating when I started thinking of writing this commentary. After speaking to many concerned Singaporeans and thinking about it more intensely, I am giving it a six.” What’s your assessment?
Balji’s main argument, which in my opinion reflected the sentiments of some of the more discerning social media crowd besides the concerned Singaporeans he had been talking to, was “whether the MTF had the confidence to take decision action. They are civil servants moved to senior positions based on their scholastic achievements and their track record in a risk-free environment. Even their entry into ministerial positions came through a silver platter. So when it comes to making decisions in an uncertain situation and with so little information, they make decisions that won’t affect their career progression.”
On top of that, because Lawrence Wong and Ong Ye Kung, two of the co-chairs, were perceived to be leading 4G contenders to take over the national leadership since Mr East Coast Plan and Mr Cotton had gone sideways, why would they want to jeopardise their golden paths by being too clever by half? headtopics.com
This was what I wrote two weeks ago: “The MTF’s record since December 2020? A mixed bag of results. Low fatalities but at a price – a patient but restless community and a disrupted economy.- Advertisement -“I believe it is also in some kind of dilemma…the MTF is risk-averse…The government’s hope is that this battle against Covid-19 would be the crucible on which the 4G leaders earn their bond with Singaporeans. Because they are being watched, Lawrence Wong and company would understandably be less inclined to take big risks. Or should they – now?”
The real test for Wong and Ong (and Gan Kim Yong) is now taking place as they prepare Singaporeans for a new phase of the battle.Ong said on Friday (Sept 25): “Singapore’s current case count of 1,600 cases a day translates to about 26 cases per 100,000 population. In contrast, countries such as America and Britain are seeing about 40 to 50 cases per 100,000 population, while the corresponding figure for other European countries that have reached an equilibrium is about seven to 10.”
The MTF’s strategy for arriving at a “new equilibrium” is being presented as an unavoidable best-case scenario. If I may interpret: “We have avoided the cost of many lives, we are now well vaccinated and better protected, the economy has to get back on its feet and move on or we will suffer permanent damage, we will ramp up healthcare facilities. We will experience large waves of cases in the four-figure range (with 5,000 a day not ruled out) as we undergo the rite of passage to the new endemic normal of living with the virus.”
- Advertisement -Sounds sensible and rational? After all these months of circuit-breaker, heightened alert, stone-by-stone calibrated approach, no Big Bang, the MTF is prepared to bite the bullet – or face the consequences of being excessively cautious. headtopics.com
Two very big stones or obstacles will test the MTF’s resolve and wits. These have been quietly left out of the main narrative of returning to a new normal.What are we going to do with the300,000 migrant workers in the dormitories? For the time being, the government says it will release 500 workers to specific location in a trial re-entry programme. MTF daily updates have mentioned a number of virus cases already detected among dormitory workers (unclear where).
And there are thereported 350,000 Malaysian workerswho used to move up and down the Causeway every day. Unconfirmed reports say half of these have returned. What are the virus risks here?- Advertisement -These two groups of people are not small. What are the long-term plans for their re-entry and re-integration?
At the same time, the search for the New Equilibrium would be a great opportunity for the 4G leaders to spell out what kind of post-pandemic Singapore they have worked out or envisioned for younger Singaporeans. What has dealing with Covid-19 taught these leaders? The healthcare system, education, economy, jobs, caring for the less fortunate fellow citizens, social responsibilities, problem-solving – what have they learnt to make them better leaders as they work for a better Singapore?
If it is not possible to do all this at the MTF press conferences, they can and should use other platforms to talk about their experiences.The MTF should not be just about numbers. The Coronavirus pandemic must surely be one of the most pivotal events in history. headtopics.com
Hence, I am not giving the MTF any rating just yet. History – or maybe the 2025 general elections – will be the final arbiter.Tan Bah Bah, consulting editor of TheIndependent.Sg, is a former senior leader writer with The Straits Times. He was also managing editor of a local magazine publishing company
.Follow us on Social MediaSend in your scoops to email@example.com Read more: The Independent »
Household members dining-in in groups of 5, team sports could be allowed if weekly Covid-19 infection rate falls: Lawrence Wong
That's generous and forgiving. So high marks arh?
2 elderly Singaporeans die of Covid-19 complications; death toll hits 78SINGAPORE — Two elderly Singaporean women, both unvaccinated and with underlying medical conditions, have died from complications due to Covid-19 over the past two days, the Ministry of Health (MOH) said on Sunday (Sept 26).
Record 1,650 new Covid-19 cases in Singapore, including 4 imported onesSINGAPORE — Singapore registered a record high of new Covid-19 cases for the second consecutive day on Friday (Sept 24) with 1,650 infections, surpassing Thursday’s record daily tally of 1,504 cases.
Sydney set to unveil freedom roadmap as more COVID-19 curbs easedSYDNEY: Australia\u0027s New South Wales government plans to unveil its roadmap on Monday (Sep 27) for reopening the state from COVID-19 shutdowns, detailing the differing levels of freedoms to be afforded to citizens based on their vaccination status. With 60 per cent of people aged 16 and above fully ino
3 more COVID-19 deaths as Singapore reports 1,650 new casesSINGAPORE: Singapore reported 1,650 new COVID-19 cases as of noon on Friday (Sep 24), rising for the fourth consecutive day. The 1,646 local infections comprise 1,369 community cases and 277 dormitory residents. There were also four imported cases, Reading the details about the clusters and subsequently the concentration of infections at least for me it didn't disclose any correlation with the severe restrictive measurements set for the entire population. Perhaps some more info s needed to understand better
3 Singaporean elderly men die of Covid-19 complications; death toll reaches 73SINGAPORE — Three Singaporean men aged 79, 83 and 86 with underlying health conditions have died from complications due to Covid-19 on Friday (Sept 24), said the Ministry of Health (MOH). That’s a grim reminder for myself and everyone else too that we shouldn’t be, at this phase, at this age to have any serious medical conditions - especially the three high risk “friends” - because we can avoid all these. 🥺 Stop restricting our outdoors doubles tennis games for elders!!!!
No plans for mandatory COVID-19 vaccinations in Singapore: MOH officialThere are no plans to make COVID-19 vaccinations mandatory as the Pfizer-BioNTech and Moderna vaccines used in Singapore have not been fully registered, said a senior Ministry of Health official.