'Bad math': Airlines ' COVID safety analysis challenged by expert
Dr. David Freedman, a US infectious diseases specialist, said he declined to take part in a recent presentation by global airline body IATA with planemakers Airbus, Boeing and Embraer that cited his work.While he welcomed some industry findings as "encouraging", Freedman said a key assertion about the improbability of catching COVID-19 on planes was based on "bad math".
Airlines and planemakers are anxious to restart international travel, even as a second wave of infections and restrictions take hold in many countries.The Oct. 8 media presentation listed in-flight infections reported in scientific studies or by IATA airlines, and compared the tally with total passenger journeys this year.
"With only 44 identified potential cases of flight-related transmission among 1.2 billion travellers, that's one case for every 27 million," IATA medical adviser Dr David Powell said in a news release, echoed in comments during the event.
IATA said its findings "align with the low numbers reported in a recently published peer-reviewed study by Freedman and Wilder-Smith".But Freedman, who co-authored the paper in the Journal of Travel Medicine, said he took issue with IATA's risk calculation because the reported count bore no direct relation to the unknown real number of infections.
"They wanted me at that press conference to present the stuff, but honestly I objected to the title they had put on it," the University of Alabama academic told Reuters."It was bad math. 1.2 billion passengers during 2020 is not a fair denominator because hardly anybody was tested. How do you know how many people really got infected?" he said. "The absence of evidence is not evidence of absence."
IATA maintains that its calculation is a "relevant and credible" sign of low risk, a spokesman said in response to requests for comment from the organisation and its top medic Powell."We've not claimed it's a definitive and absolute number."
The head of British Airways directly invoked the 1-in-27 million ratio to press for a lifting of quarantines on Monday."We know public safety is key for the government, so it should be reassured by IATA's new figures," Chief Executive Sean Doyle told a UK aviation conference.
Freedman's research partner Dr Annelies Wilder-Smith of the London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine could not immediately be reached for comment.CLOSING RANKSWhile the pandemic has seen some carriers leave middle seats empty to reassure customers, the industry has opposed making such measures mandatory.
Plane cabins are considered lower-risk than many indoor spaces because of their powerful ventilation and their layout, with forward-facing passengers separated by seat rows. Ceiling-to-floor airflows sweep pathogens into high-grade filters.That understanding is supported by simulations and tests run by the aircraft makers as well as a U.S. Defense Department study released on Thursday.
The joint presentation with all three manufacturers signalled a rare closing of ranks among industrial arch-rivals, behind a message designed to reassure.Sitting beside an infected economy passenger is comparable to seven-foot distancing in an office, Boeing tests concluded, posing an acceptably low risk with masks. Standard health advice often recommends a six-foot separation.
Airbus showed similar findings, while Embraer tested droplet dispersal from a cough. Some 0.13% by mass ended up in an adjacent passenger's facial area, falling to 0.02% with masks.Dr Henry Wu, associate professor at Atlanta's Emory School of Medicine, said the findings were inconclusive on their own because the minimum infective dose remains unknown, and risks increase in step with exposure time.
"It's simply additive," said Wu, who would prefer middle seats to be left empty. "A 10-hour flight will be 10 times riskier than a one-hour flight."Nonetheless, a commercial jet cabin is "probably one of the safer public settings you can be in", he added. "Sitting at a crowded bar for a few hours is going to be much riskier."
'SUPERSPREADER EVENTS'Scientists are poring over dozens of on-board infection cases, as well as flights with contagious passengers but no known transmission.In March, 11 infectious passengers on a five-hour Sydney-Perth flight passed the virus to 11 others, according to a paper in the Emerging Infectious Diseases journal.
Among those infected, two were seated three rows away from a contagious passenger and one was six rows away, suggesting that typical two-row contact-tracing might have missed them.One sufferer on a 10-hour London-Hanoi flight the same month infected 16 others including 12 in her business-class cabin, according to a study by Vietnamese and Australian academics.
"Long flights ... can provide conditions for superspreader events," the study said, adding that its findings "challenge" the airlines' assertion that on-board distancing is unnecessary.IATA points out that many of the flights examined by scientists in published studies occurred before mask-wearing became widespread and reduced infection risks.
Its presentation did concede that the 44-case tally "may be an underestimate", while maintaining that in-flight infections remained less likely than a lightning strike even if only 10% of actual cases had made the count. Read more: ABS-CBN News Channel »
[PODCAST] Bakit si Debold Sinas ang piniling maging bagong PNP chief?
Ano ang dapat abangan sa pamumuno ni PNP chief Debold Sinas?
Enchong bad trip kay Celine Pialago: Ilagay mo ang sarili sa kalagayan ng isang ina at mangyari ito sa ‘yo?“THIS person is Heartless and Unintelligent. Ilagay mo ang sarili sa kalagayan ng isang ina at mangyari ito sa ’yo? Bilang isang tao, okay lang talaga sa ’yo?” Ito ang sagot ng aktor na si Enchong Dee sa Facebook post ni MMDA Spokesperson Asec. Celine Pialago nitong Linggo. May kinalaman ang post ni Asec Pialago […] banderainquirer Buti pa si Mayor Enchong may awa at pag-iintende kahit lalaki at wala pang anak. This Celine is a bitch! banderainquirer nako, tatagan mo naun loob mo enchong, tatadtadin ka ng bash ng mga ddsbulag, magiging NPA or terorista ka na sa mata nila. banderainquirer Naku enchong if kabit mentality ung girl walang paki-alam yan sa mga anak at babies. Heartless and selfish kasig ugali. 😅
Persons with 'long COVID' no longer infectious - medical expert - Manila BulletinPatients with “long COVID” are no longer infectious, Dr. Rontgene Solante, head of Adult Infectious Diseases in San Lazaro Hospital, said on Monday. At ano naman yun 'short covid' Ilabas na kc lahat lahat mg impormasyon ukol sa virus...
A COVID-19 survivor reflects on fighting the disease and the discrimination COVID-19 survivor Katrina Castilla bravely shares how she survived COVID-19 and the social stigma that surrounds it, on gma_lifestyle's 'New Normal' web series.
Fast food chain launches free COVID testing for employees - Manila BulletinThere have been more than four million tests for the coronavirus disease ( COVID-19 ) conducted in the country, the National Task Force (NTF) Against COVID-19 said.
As more people go out, police adjust health safety measuresJTF Covid Shield tells all police commanders to recalibrate strategies in implementing health safety measures such as wearing of face masks and face shields, and observing physical distancing. Read
Virgin coconut oil a potential antiviral agent vs COVID-19, research showsExperiments have shown evidence that virgin coconut oil may defeat the new coronavirus disease ( COVID-19 ). You need to explicitly state in the article that scientists recommend not to try it yet. Some might read this and run to hoard VCO. It will be flying around Viber groups by noon and raise false hopes. 'Gasolina pa din kami' - Pinoy Wumao