Controversial Electoral bill exposes Nigerian lawmakers - Punch Newspapers
The most widely read newspaper in Nigeria
24 July 2021SUNDAY ABORISADE highlights the views of experts and stakeholders on the implications of two bills recently passed by the National Assembly aimed at guaranteeing free, fair and credible elections in NigeriaLast week, the two chambers of the National Assembly passed the Electoral Act (Amendment ) Bill 2021 and the Electoral Offences Establishment Bill as part of efforts to ensure that Nigerians’ votes count during polls.
While the bill seeking to establish a commission that would be saddled with the responsibilities of prosecuting electoral offenders was passed without much ado, that of amendment to the Electoral Act generated serious controversies both in the Senate and the House of Representatives.
The Electoral Offences bill, among other provisions, okayed a 20-year jail term for anybody caught snatching ballot materials.The Joint Senate and House Committee on Independent National Electoral Commission in Clause 52(3) provides for electronic transmission of election results by INEC where and when practicable but the All Progressives Congress senators rejected it and voted for an amendment made by Senator Aliyu Abdullahi ( APC Niger North) . headtopics.com
Abdullahi had added a proviso that “INEC may consider electronic transmission of results provided the national network coverage is adjudged to be adequate and secure by the Nigerian Communications Commission and approved by the National Assembly.”However, the Peoples Democratic Party Senators stuck to the recommendation of the joint panel which states that, “The Commission (INEC) may transmit results of elections by electronic means where and when practicable.”
The voice vote adopted by the President of the Senate, Ahmad Lawan, to determine the winner in favour of the APC, was rejected by the Senate Minority Leader , Enyinnaya Abaribe, and he called for a division after a stalemate which could not be resolved behind closed doors.
The Clerk of the Senate, Ibrahim El–Ladan, conducted the headcount and a total of 80 Senators voted; while 50 APC senators and two from the PDP voted for the amendment made by Abdullahi, 28 PDP lawmakers voted for the original provision of the clause.
The clerk said 28 senators were absent during the division and voting session.In the House of Representatives, however, the original provision recommended by the joint panel was retained but members of the opposition PDP staged a walk-out, following an unsuccessful attempt to make it mandatory for INEC to transmit election results, electronically. headtopics.com
Stakeholders and experts who expressed their views on the developments, however, expressed divergent opinions.For instance, the Executive Director, Yiaga Africa, Samson Itodo, kicked against the version passed by the Senate which according to him, would erode the independence of INEC.
He also said the attempt to guarantee free, fair and credible elections in Nigeria would be a mirage if such a provision was retained.Itodo said, “it is important to underscore the fact that the bill as passed by both chambers of the National Assembly is not a law yet until the President assents his signature to the bill.
“Given all the controversies and how both the Senate and the House of Representatives voted, it is clear that there is a consensus among lawmakers from the ruling APC to maintain the status quo as it relates to results collation and transmission and not to adopt an electronic transmission of results for subsequent elections.
“This is a testament to the fact that the beneficiaries of a jaundice, very porous, vulnerable results collation process do not want to end these level of vulnerability and compromise that has plagued results collation over the years and it is disturbing. This is because over the years, it has encouraged election rigging and results falsification and they don’t want to introduce technology that would curb that fraud. That is why Nigerians should resist it with their attempt to exclude INEC from electronic transmission of results.” headtopics.com
He further explained, “The electronic transmission of results as contemplated within our electoral process is to serve as a check on the manual process and not necessarily replace or supplant the manual process of collating election results with the electronic transmission.
“Results collation happens at different levels depending on the elections. It can happen at the ward, local, state and national levels. The decentralised stages of results collation to a large extent, also serve as a check. We need to note that the integrity of the 2023 elections is going to be hinged on how results are collated, transmitted and how declarations are made. If there is an attempt to stop or preclude INEC from transmitting results electronically, we are simply saying goodbye to election integrity in 2023.”
On the 20-year jail term prescribed for ballot box snatchers, in the new bill, Itodo said, “I don’t think it will end electoral violence. On one hand, it is not about having a legislation, it is about holding defaulters to account. Politicians are the main culprit.”
He added, “They are the ones who made the law, and they are the ones who also compromise the judiciary. At the end of the day, I doubt if it will end electoral violence. I just feel that it shouldn’t be limited to those who snatch ballot boxes, the sponsors should also be captured in the law because they are the real beneficiaries of ballot box snitching. We should look for a way to sanction conspirators, their sponsors, and not just the perpetrators of the act.”
The National General Secretary, Campaign for Democracy, Ifeanyi Odili, said the electronic transmission of results was rejected by the retrogressive members of the National Assembly while the real progressives among then embraced it.Odili said, “The end result of the electronic transmission of results will be very productive, un-hazardous, helpful and would not be counter-productive.
“This is because it will prevent candidates heading to challenge election results in the election petition tribunal, since everybody would have been in possession of the results as they keep coming in before the official announcement.“The staggered elections we have today in Nigeria is a consequence of election rigging and the attended legal battles. If we imbibe this culture, snatching of ballot boxes will become history. Rejecting the bill can only come from retrogressive minds.
“I want to draw an inference here that if we take a critical look at the foundation of the lawmakers who are opposed to it, it would be readily concluded that they are the ones who got elected through the back door, I mean those who subverted the wishes of the electorate to get to position.
“I have a strong feeling that any lawmaker that is opposed to it has a retrogressive mind who found his or her way to the hallowed chambers though the back door. I mean they are the real products of election fraud.”He further pointed, “It is appalling and absurd to hear that in this computer age and the global spread of the ICT, a federal lawmaker, very popular on social media, could oppose electronic transmission of results. Such affected lawmakers should have their brains examined by medical experts. Also, asking INEC to seek approval from the Nigerian Communications Commission and the National Assembly cannot work because it will compromise the independence of INEC.
“That will strip the commission of its independence. That opinion can only come from the pit of hell.”Odili said the establishment of a commission to try electoral offenders would curb rigging and violence during polls.He said, “Our people are stone-hearted, very difficult to predict. However, it is good tactics to stop snatching of ballot boxes.
“With this bill, I can see that we are heading somewhere. It is abnormal and insane for any person to snatch ballot boxes because it is subversive. It takes the entire process backward.“However, a 20-year jail term is not enough punishment for someone who subverts our collective wishes, it is treasonable, it is mutiny and should be treated as such.”
A human rights activist, who represented the Kaduna Central Senatorial District in the 8th National Assembly, Senator Shehu Sani, said there could be chaos and anarchy if the National Assembly passed the Senate version of the Electoral Act (Amendment ) Bill.
Sani said, “There are three implications of the clause passed by the Senate on the 2023 general elections.“First, the independence of INEC has been compromised. We now have three electoral bodies-the real INEC, the NCC and the National Assembly.“The second implication is that the ruling party with dominance in the National Assembly, would now be determining whether the results of an election conducted by the INEC should be released or not.Read more: The Punch Newspapers »
We Cannot Learn, We Get Drenched Once It Rains, Pupils Of Idaw Primary School Enugu Cry Out | Punch
Pupils of Idaw River Primary School 1 in Enugu have called on the government of Ifeanyi Uguwanyi to save their school. The pupils who spoke with us revealed ...
Wolves in sheep clothing. AntiProgressiveCongress DrAhmadLawan femigbaja seems there is nothing progressive about APC. So appalling for democracy. ShehuSani AishaYesufu SavvyRinu mrmacaronii behold our politicians Bounch of thief’s These are two rubber stamps that will be judged along with Buhari after 2023 ,they have long being exposed .....
There's nothing to expose. Res ipsa loquitur, It has been obvious all the time.
NBC’s controversial memo and increasing bullying of the media - Punch NewspapersThe most widely read newspaper in Nigeria One of the ways to reverse this unhappy trend is for the NBC to become less intrusive, less dictatorial and less over-bearing in playing the role of regulator lest it makes the regrettable transition from regulator to undertaker of broadcast media in Nigeria. The way in which the commission, especially its chairman, is appointed: As long as the commission is a hand-maiden of government and sees itself as an extension of the Ministry of Information, so long will it be ineffectual and function as the information apparatus of government Na una d media cause dis see finish If to say na dey do una job People for vote dis cow as president before?
20 million Nigerians to benefit from UNICEF youth initiative - Punch NewspapersThe most widely read newspaper in Nigeria The useless youths we have predominantly interested in Yahoo Yahoo. And when that isn't profitable, they blame the government. No be wheelbarrow them wan share or tailoring training them wan do ba Pls remember to put Northerners....
COVID-19 testing stops in 13 states, Delta variant hitting unvaccinated NigeriansThere were indications that at least 13 states had stopped testing for COVID-19 despite the impending third wave of the disease propelled by the highly infectious Delta strain. medical bandits everywhere This man has chop covid19 money wella Can you kindly leave Delta Variant for Delta State people please? 😂
Nigerian Breweries, experts to empower craftsmen - Punch NewspapersThe most widely read newspaper in Nigeria The NB Officials got to be aware of Sharia & Hisbba in the core North. NIGERIA BREWERIES MAY END UP EMPOWERING SAME PEOPLE THAT CALL ALCHOL HARAM AND THOSE SAME PEOPLE WILL ACCEPT THE HARAM EMPOWERMENT...
Presidency, stakeholders to present startup bill in Q4 - Punch NewspapersThe most widely read newspaper in Nigeria Quality literide Crocs on sales here..it's comfy and affordable.. what app(09020352754) or DM
FACT CHECK: Bill Gates never tweeted about animal slaughtering - Punch NewspapersThe most widely read newspaper in Nigeria