'What of our public universities now? So what if some have improved in the rankings? Who cares?' - Prof Dr Mohd Tajuddin Mohd Rasdi
THE aftermath of the Malay Dignity Congress organised by four public universities – Universiti Malaya (UM), Universiti Pendidikan Sultan Idris (UPSI), Universiti Teknologi Mara (UiTM) and Universiti Putra Malaysia (UPM) – has left Malaysians pondering a simple question:
Even I, already a known critic of our universities’ contribution to nation building, was shocked at the blatant and unashamed speeches by academics and students at the Congress that virtually destroyed whatever there is left of the idea and ideals of Malaysia as a shared nation between different faiths and cultures.
Only the sensible voice of Tun Dr Mahathir Mohamad managed to turn the tables on those so-called academics and their political partners, shocking them with a traumatic backlash.“It’s your own fault, dear Malays, ” was what Dr Mahathir basically said.The academics gave speeches against non-Malays by citing examples that had no academic worth at all.
That a university would propose such a “congress” without inviting opposing viewpoints while barring other races from attending, smacked clearly of a political agenda that violates the ideals of academic scholarship.Three years ago, I remember calling a reporter for an interview on the fate of Malaysia in the near future, with the 14th General Election (GE14) looming ahead.
The reporter was interested in what I had to say and asked the important question; what would happen to Malaysia if such-and-such a party won the election?My answer, I could see, was most disappointing to her. So much so that she ultimately reported only a single paragraph of what I had deliberated on.
What was my response? I remember saying that it does not matter which party wins because the fate of the country lies with what happens to three players: universities, and the academics and students of these universities.I could sense that the reporter thought that I was being extremely silly and mired in self-importance simply because I was a professor and the whole world surrounds academia.
What she failed to understand was that as academics, we spend our lives understanding the root of problems, not just the problem itself. The PhD process forces you to peel off any problem to its very root and kernel, and then you build up a new list of questions.
We deal with the foundation of issues, and answer problems with a structured response that sees the problem decades ahead.I remember explaining that at first, universities must restructure their KPIs (key performance indicators) and make sure that research has a clear societal and environmental impact.
There is no point having an H-index of 40 by citing your own work in environmental engineering when you can’t help the 2,000 of our children who almost died of poisonous fumes from Sungai Kim Kim. There is no point getting promoted to professor or a vice-chancellorship at an “Islamic” university when Muslims use the word kafir on non-Muslims and say that only Muslims can hold top positions, even those who are known kleptocrats.
Secondly, I told the journalist, the academic must have the sense of being an agent for change in society and the nation.Academics must rewrite the narrative for the nation and not leave it up to politicians of either divide.Nowadays, most academics just want their research grant to present papers overseas and pay for their papers to be published in international journals, just so that they get the accounting for a promotion.
I have rejected many applications for a professorship in architecture because I saw no contribution to society and no legacy framework to project the discipline into changing society and the environment.Thirdly, I said that students must be taught that this country belongs to them and not to politicians.
Students must understand that if the nation fails in any way – socially, environmentally, or economically – it is due to their own apathy and narrow-mindedness.Thus, with these three important players, a nation can be rebuilt to have sustained real and genuine prosperity.
What of our public universities now? So what if some have improved in the rankings? Who cares?When a public university organised an LGBT-bashing conference some years back, it showed that the university clearly does not understand our Federal Constitution or even basic human dignity. That is the level of our academia.
When another public university organised a Christian-bashing conference, its academics were the same as those at the LGBT (lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgender) university conference.Neither university invited alternate viewpoints from LGBTs or Christians, and both conferences were closed sessions that seem more of a “briefing” than any real intellectual discourse.
Recently, Murray Hunter of Asia Sentinel gave an embarrassing dressing-down of our public universities.Firstly, he questioned the vision of public universities and noted that none was seriously interested in social change but only the production of workers.
Secondly, he mentioned that the universities are “race-biased”, emphasising a Malay administration culture.Thirdly, there was too much emphasis on Islam, and encouraging bigotry was rampant in these public universities.I have only written about Murray’s first criticism but not the other two. Now, after the Malay Dignity Congress, what he has alleged has become undeniable fact.
Professors, vice-chancellors and students were there where racism and bigotry were encouraged, applauded and celebrated.Whither now, public universities?A call for the resignation of the university leadership was made by a student body at UM. I have never supported such calls or actions before, but Malaysians must take this call under serious consideration.
The scar of the Congress runs deep, and its infection may be incurable if drastic measures are not taken.I would firstly call on the leadership of the four universities to step up to the plate and explain to the Malaysian people their excuses, and apologise for hold the Congress.
Secondly, I would like to call on the Education Ministry to appoint three civil society members to the board of directors of each of these four universities, and later on, to the boards of all the other 16 public universities.These civil society members should come from respected NGOs representing all Malaysians. I recommend working with Gabungan Bertindak Malaysia (GBM), an entity comprising multiracial and multi-faith NGOs and groups.
GBM can sit and decide who should be appointed, and submit the names for official appointment by the Ministry. The Ministry itself should have no say in these appointments as they come directly from the people.We can no longer trust academics and industrialists to fill the boards of universities; we need “people-conscious” Malaysians.
The three must be of different races and faiths and do not need to have a PhD. Judging by the Congress, a PhD or a string of papers being published in journals does not necessarily make a good Malaysian.Universities must regain the trust of the people. Malaysian taxpayers may not see much value in funding academic racism and bigotry in the near future.
The writer is Professor of Architecture at UCSI University, and has been an academic at both public and private universities over the past 32 years. The writer’s views are his own. Read more: The Star »
Front page report in the S'pore Straits Times - 'Jokowi's son graduates from SUSS (S'pore University of Social Sciences)'. Note that the Indonesian President's son, who could have studied in most any university, chose to study in S'pore..unimalaya maszlee mahadir tu kuat putar alam,jaga2. ku li boleh urus.
Separate church and state. When politicians fail to address the problems in the society, the academia plays its role. They are backwards people. Wonderful letter written by Prof Dr Tajuddin, I'm most appreciative of his razor sharp insights. We need more ppl like him to step up n lead the way with intellect, compassion n common sense.
Finally an intellectual who can see the folly of our academia! (Sigh of relief...) But still many government universities students fail to be on priority for government jobs. What’s the point they struggle so hard to enter public universities.. Unsurprising, they r still mired wt d 'bodek' game in so-called New Malaysia, particularly wt whoever d politician that holds d Minister's position.
make these vice-chancellors answer The future of the country looks so bright, doesn’t it? Brainwashed factories? 🕯️education universities “Whatever the cost of our libraries, the price is cheap compared to that of an ignorant nation.” ― Walter Cronkite it's plain to see who are the racists and bigots. That's the good thing that came out of this,
Hishammuddin: Malay Dignity Congress an effort to unite community | Malay MailKUALA LUMPUR, Oct 7 — Malay Dignity Congress is an effort to unite Malays and stop politicking, said Umno’s Datuk Seri Hishammuddin Hussein. He said all Malay politicians regardless of affiliation should support the effort as it was for the good of the community. “I think we have to move... Isn't that the work of the sultans and agongs? I thought that was the reason for retaining our royalty after Merdeka. Gee! Then why not call it the 'Malay Unity Congress'? By calling a Dignity Congress, it might be misconstrued as a apathied, Nazi , white supremacists movement Why have one royal when you can have at least 9 to do the vital religious duties.
21 still warded after food poisoning at Malay Dignity Congress | Malay MailSHAH ALAM, Oct 7 — Twenty One of the 197 university students who suffered food poisoning at the Malay Dignity Congress here yesterday are still being treated at hospitals. Selangor Health director Datuk Dr. Khalid Ibrahim said 20 students were treated at Tuanku Ampuan Rahimah Hospital, Klang... Not much dignity ! too much enjoying free meal
CenBet wants govt to make stand on issues raised at Malay Dignity CongressPETALING JAYA: The government needs to set the record straight on its stance over the resolutions raised during Sunday's Malay Dignity Congress.
Malay Dignity Congress exposes Mahathir's hypocrisy: Gerakan VPMahathir's insincerity in solving problems of all Malaysians surfaced when he showed up at the congress. Another wise words from irrelevant political party. Apa ni gerakan? Gerak ke mana? Mahathir unite all party. No bias. Get along all party.
Anwar's speech slur on Malay Dignity Congress draws comments from PM's aideZahid Md Arip says mispronouncing one letter could lead to problems, after Anwar Ibrahim is heard saying 'barua' instead of 'maruah'. FMTNews Alahhhhhh ini pun nak jadikan issue, pi kerja la
Police to investigate Malay Dignity Congress organiser Zainal Kling | The Malaysian InsightBukit Aman confirms investigation for causing public mischief underway.