Technology, Internet, Cryptocurrency, Nft

Technology, Internet

Op-Ed: NFTs are digital tulip fever: Would you pay thousands for a bar code?

Or millions for a digital painting?

14/5/2021 6:50:00 AM

Or millions for a digital painting?

What is this beautiful, special thing you acquire when you buy an NFT ?

Digging into Foundation's website, the limitations of NFTs become clear. The site's"Community Guidelines" state that a collector of an NFT"can't claim legal ownership, copyrights, trademarks, or other intellectual property rights" to a work. What the buyer acquires is an"NFT that represents the artwork on the blockchain."

Low spec phones: Why ask for chicken when given free sardines, says Perak MB China to give M'sia 500k Sinovac doses, Hisham thanks 'big brother' Wang 'Telefon pintar sumbangan Yayasan YTL, sesuai untuk pelajar ikuti PdPR' | Harian Metro

This crypto-jargon is rarely unpacked. In layman's terms it means that when you purchase an NFT you are literally buying an entry in an online ledger — which is to say data on a"blockchain." Most often an NFT-affiliated artwork will be a digital file of an image, a video or an animation. The blockchain doesn't contain this file, or only very rarely. Rather, it contains a link to a database where a copy of the file is stored.

While crypto-art enthusiasts make much of the uniqueness of NFTs, they are unique in the way a bar code is. A bar code is a distinct identifier associated with an object, say a pair of sneakers or a can of sardines. Bar codes enable stores to keep track of inventory; NFTs allow keepers of a blockchain to keep track of transactions about a file.

As to what's in this file: It may be best thought of as a representation of an artwork. There may well be more than one such representation (just as there are multiple cans of sardines), each with its own blockchain entry and its own NFT. Canadian musician Grimes made several million dollars selling hundreds of NFTs for copies of two short videos with cherub images.

In a sense this is the digital equivalent of a photograph or print that's part of a numbered edition. One difference with an NFT is that the exact image it links to is probably available online for anyone to enjoy as much as the collector who's paid thousands of dollars for a token.

Sometimes, NFTs are connected to physical things, as was the case with the disappearing Basquiat. High-end sneakers, expensive streetwear and baseball cards are some of the items now on offer via NFTs, which act here as a kind of ownership certificate. In the spirit of Andy Warhol, I'd like to mint an NFT for a can of Campbell's soup.

It's possible the creator of an NFT-affiliated work may also sell its copyright as part of the deal. The Basquiat sellers claimed to be offering"all related IP and copyright in perpetuity." (IP being"intellectual property.") Yet this is the exception. Most"minters" of NFTs retain subsidiary rights.

Singer Ismail Izzani told off by followers for sharing shirtless photos that ‘encourage others to sin’ | Malay Mail Ramai tauke udang galah bakal 'gulung tikar' | Harian Metro Saifuddin tells why there's no total lockdown now

Perhaps the rights NFT collectors most highly value are bragging rights: They can say they"own" a work. Yet their copy has no special qualities aside from its NFT, so under the hood of the hype, the frenzy is about the token, in which there is now a booming secondary market.

It's hard not to see this as a case of digital tulip fever. Can you imagine paying millions of dollars for a bar code? Then again, perhaps this is the apotheosis of Warhol's soup can strategies — attributing value to that which seems the most banal.

Art NFTs put me in mind of film auteur Werner Herzog's distinction between the"truth of accountants" and"ecstatic truth." NFT mavens wax lyrical about the"authenticity" of these tokens as if they are trading a semi-divine quality, yet the authenticity encoded by an NFT is the same kind encoded by a transaction number on a credit card statement. They are a dressed-up species of bookkeeping. What art needs is less auditing and more ecstasy.

Moreover, there are serious legal issues. Will databases containing NFT-linked files disappear, as Myspace did? Already, defunct links have caused collectors to lose access to files. If an artist or minter forgets the"seed phrase" (a passcode) to their"digital wallet," they lose access to the proceeds of sales with no recovery path.

And does the minter really own the underlying work, or its rights? Fraud is rife. Scams abound. Misunderstandings, shall we say. The Basquiat sellers seem to have misunderstood basic copyright law.On April 28, the artist's estate intervened in the Basquiat offer."No license or rights were conveyed to the seller," we learned. The drawing's owner could not legally reproduce it or reuse it in any way. It all went pfft — there was no legitimate NFT.

So, buyer, beware. The real value in NFTs may well be this: a bonanza for copyright lawyers. – Los Angeles Times/TNS Read more: The Star »

Kedah MB was buying food and not going for a test drive, claims aide

ALOR SETAR: The political secretary to Muhammad Sanusi Md Nor denies that the Kedah Mentri Besar violated standard operating procedures (SOP) during the lockdown by going for a test drive here on Saturday (June 5).

NFT is just digital form of Sotheby's, instead some old currency notes, coin or paintings, right now is a bar code or tweets. At the end, is just another rich man's games.

Police identify individual who smashed road barrier cones in Taiping | The Malaysian InsightPolice have identified the individual believed to have damaged road barrier cones at the intersection of Jalan Simpang Halt to Jalan Perusahaan Kamunting Raya in Taiping used to curb inter-district travel on Monday.

How to create your own MySejahtera QR code for your home | Malay MailKUALA LUMPUR, May 13 ― Hari Raya Aidilfitri celebrations this year are set to be a wholly different affair, with the government imposing nationwide movement control order (MCO) from May 12 until the June 7, 2021. This also means that all home visits and visits to the cemetery are not allowed...

Portugal investigates mass gathering of football fans amid pandemicLISBON (Reuters) -Portugal's government said on Wednesday it was investigating how a mass gathering of thousands of Sporting fans celebrating their club being crowned Portuguese champions got out of hand.

Terengganu: Solat Aidilfitri dibenarkan dengan 40 jemaah lelaki - Utusan DigitalBagi solat fardu lima waktu pula jumlah jemaah tidak melebihi 20 orang di masjid dan surau seluruh negeri.

Jelitawan sukan raya sederhana - Utusan DigitalSelamat Hari Raya Aidilfitri buat seluruh rakyat Malaysia. KitaJagaKita

Alif Syukri sedih, lembu dan kambing sudah tempah - Utusan DigitalAlif Syukri sedih, lembu dan kambing sudah tempah