Jonathan English, Toronto, Transit, Suburban Transit, Busses, Suburban Busses, Suburb, Climate Change, Cities

Jonathan English, Toronto

Opinion: Toronto’s secret success: Suburban buses

Toronto’s secret success: Suburban buses @GlobeDebate

2019-10-25 7:06:00 PM

Toronto ’s secret success: Suburb an buses GlobeDebate

It’s a model that shows how to make transit work for the cities we have today and not the imagined cities of the future

<Jonathan English is a Toronto-based PhD candidate in urban planning at Columbia University.In discussions about the recipe for transit success, the key ingredient is always land use. Is there enough density? Is it walkable?Certainly, these elements are very important. But the assumption that land use must be perfect for transit to succeed has led to fatalism about the fate of transit in neighbourhoods built around the car. Climate change is an imminent crisis. We need a way to get people out of their cars faster than we can rebuild the suburbs where most people live. Fortunately, Canadian cities such as Toronto are a model of successful transit in seemingly unlikely environments.

Peel police investigating death of 27-year-old man found lying on ground in Mississauga park Jonathan Kay: How the left's obsession with American-style culture wars corroded Canadian identity Dr. Masri on AstraZeneca guidance

Story continues below advertisementTransit fatalism has meant governments have rarely deigned to provide decent transit service in suburbs. The problem is common sense, although often overlooked: Demand will never materialize without decent service. People can’t take a train or bus trip that doesn’t exist. Governments are reluctant to improve service when existing ridership is poor. But it will stay poor forever if the service is never improved.

Toronto’s transit is unquestionably imperfect – all riders have endured unreliable schedules and overcrowded vehicles, and many routes still aren’t as fast or frequent as they should be – but it is still leaps and bounds above transit in most American cities. In the early 1960s, Metropolitan Toronto’s political leadership and the Toronto Transit Commission made the conscious decision to provide a grid of frequent bus service in the new suburbs as they were built.

This was in stark contrast to nearly every American city at that time, where new cul-de-sacs had little or no transit service at all. Today, buses along the city of Toronto’s major suburban streets are scheduled every 10 minutes or more until late at night.

By contrast, even in a relatively transit-friendly metropolitan area such as New York, the Long Island suburbs (population: nearly three million) have only two routes that run daily every half-hour until midnight – a minimal standard. Most routes run hourly or worse, and many stop around 6 p.m. and don’t run on weekends. That’s not a service that anyone with a choice would use, but it describes the majority of routes in U.S. cities.

Toronto, Montreal and the far denser five boroughs of New York have by far the highest transit ridership per capita in North America. While many people ride transit in downtown Boston or San Francisco, ridership is modest in their suburbs. In Toronto’s suburbs, some of the bus routes are among the busiest on the continent – more than 40,000 riders a day, exceeding all but a few in Brooklyn and Manhattan. (The busiest bus corridor is the one on Broadway in Vancouver, which makes a strong case for its planned subway.)

There are established formulas for transit service that deem many parts of suburban Toronto too low-density to support more than one bus an hour. When I speak to U.S. audiences and show them pictures of Finch Avenue in Toronto, they all say that they’d expect it to have hourly service. And yet, Finch has peak scheduled service every 90 seconds – better than every five minutes off-peak – and those buses are packed. It performs better financially than even busy downtown streetcar routes. These formulas shape policy in countless cities, including in Canada, and they need to be revised in light of Canadian experience.

Massive restoration of Parliament’s Centre Block to cost up to $5-billion Alberta man says AstraZeneca shot led to serious health issue, wants federal compensation Liberal government found in contempt of Parliament in Commons vote

Even though the TTC provides far more frequent bus service than any American transit operator, the ensuing crowds mean that the TTC is far less subsidized than any other major transit agency in North America. About 70 per cent of its costs are covered by fares, compared with 47 per cent in New York and only 30 per cent in Boston.

Story continues below advertisementStory continues below advertisementFrequent bus service makes connections possible, as Australian scholar Paul Mees has observed, so people can transfer from one bus to another for cross-suburban trips without having to worry about waiting forever if they miss the connection.

Frequent bus service also helps us get far better value for the subways that we build. Toronto has a fairly small subway system compared with many peer cities, but it’s by far the busiest per kilometre (along with Montreal) in North America.Why? Because instead of relying on people having to drive to limited parking lots or to walk to stations, the catchment area of stations can be much larger because people arrive by bus. Take Warden Station, for example. It’s surrounded by forest and low-density housing – about the least clement transit environment imaginable. Yet, it has 39,980 riders a day because people can easily transfer to and from a frequent feeder bus, compared with about 18,000 at Bethesda in suburban Washington, which is surrounded by dense offices and condos but has poorer bus connections.

Toronto is no transit utopia, as we all know. It’s shocking that many of these bus routes, which are among the busiest on the continent, don’t have any meaningful transit priority, let alone their own lanes. Worse, the transit success story doesn’t extend past the City of Toronto boundary into the 905 region, even in similarly dense neighbourhoods.

York Region Transit is spending $2-billion on bus rapid transit infrastructure, but some BRT routes are only every 20 minutes – and other routes are as infrequent as in U.S. cities. There are rays of hope, however: Brampton has recently emulated the Toronto model by implementing a grid of bus routes that run frequently all day. The upshot? A greater than 40-per-cent increase in per-capita ridership from 2009 to 2014.

Across North America, there has been a revival in the respect for the humble bus as a means of moving thousands of people quietly and relatively cheaply. It doesn’t require billions in spending or years of construction to provide a frequent bus service.

Systemic racism in policing a real and pressing problem: parliamentary committee North Korea's Kim vows to be ready for confrontation with U.S. MPs study of systemic racism in policing concludes RCMP needs new model

Story continues below advertisementToronto is a model that has much to offer for rethinking how to make the bus work as effective transit that people use. It shows how to make transit work for the cities we have today and not the imagined cities of the future.

Read more: The Globe and Mail »

Plays of the Week: Caufield bangs home first playoff goal and Vas stands tall -

All the best plays from the past 7 days from the Stanley Cup Playoffs, including Habs rookie Cole Caufield banging home his first career playoff goal, Vasilevskiy standing tall to deny the Isles multiple times, and Carey Price just doing his thing.

GlobeDebate I question Warden station being surrounded by forest and low density housing. Has the author even gotten off the subway to have a look around?

‘I just want to brighten a corner’: Toronto artist creates massive mural in middle of midtownThe newest piece of public art in Toronto is a 10-storey mural that features a giant deer and was painted by an artist with a secret identity. Now much did this cost the Canadians tax payer WellandGood Karsinizda bir salak varsa siz otomatik olarak akilli oluyorsunuz

The Toronto Raptors’ insane championship rings contain 640 diamonds, 17 rubies and the Toronto skylineThe Toronto Raptors' insane championship rings contain 640 diamonds, 17 rubies and the Toronto skyline Wow cool maybe that’s where all the mental health funding went It's a nice ring but should have used a few different stones. Some detail like the buildings get lost in it cause the color all blends This is obscene.

Toronto Ultra unveiled as Toronto's newest esports franchise - Sportsnet.caThe Toronto Ultra is the newest professional esports team in the city that will compete in the forthcoming Call of Duty League, which is set to launch in 2020. loung_s has the details ⤵️ loung_s The military is going to hire these guys to control drones and other machines right?

Elton John’s Goodbye Yellow Brick Road tour is the Rocket Man’s final stageElton John’s Goodbye Yellow Brick Road tour is the Rocket Man’s final stage GlobeArts

Pozuelo’s late penalty lifts Toronto FC past New York City FC in MLS playoffsPozuelo’s late penalty lifts Toronto FC past New York City FC in MLS playoffs Globe_Sports Globe_Sports Huge win!! Toronto has another gem of a team that deserves a lot of attention!! Globe_Sports 👍

Workforce women tapped to fund success of Canada’s female athletesCanfund says it has put over $40-million in the pockets of Canada’s athletes since 2003 and sent cheques to 80 per cent who competed in Olympic Games from 2004 to 2018 Globe_Sports We need more of this! Supporting amateur athletes should be a top priority of our government!